War On Terror Has Targeted Muslims Almost Exclusively – OpEd

By Maha Hilal*

Every year on September 11, the United States mourns the innocent lives that were lost in the terrorist attacks of 2001.

Each year I remember these victims, too. But I also mourn the often forgotten victims of the never-ending wars and draconian counter-terrorism policies of the post 9-11 world: the Muslim community.

In a speech to Congress shortly after the attacks, then-President Bush addressed a portion to Muslims. “The enemy of America is not our many Muslim friends; it is not our many Arab friends,” he said. “Our enemy is a radical network of terrorists, and every government that supports them.” Yet despite Bush’s attempt to distinguish between the “good” and “bad” Muslims, the war on terror has targeted the Muslim community at large almost exclusively.

Abroad, several Muslim nations have been devastated by U.S. invasions and military operations. As of 2015, Physicians for Social Responsibility estimated that 1.3 million Iraqis, Afghans, and Pakistanis had died in the course of the war on terror — a figure the group called “conservative,” noting that it doesn’t include figures from other war zones like Yemen and Somalia. Civilian casualties run high in all of these places, and alleged combatants have died by the hundreds in U.S. military custody.

Domestically, law enforcement has systematically singled out Muslims for special abuse.

Muslim congregations and student groups have suffered intrusive surveillance. And federal agencies have systematically entrapped alleged Muslim “terrorists,” with one 2014 Human Rights Watch report finding that informants had played an active role in hatching at least 30 percent of the plots they prosecuted suspects for.

Meanwhile, so-called communication management units — where federal prison inmates are barred from virtually all contact with the outside world and other inmates — were built and used to warehouse Muslim prisoners. At one point, over 60 percent of inmates housed in them were Muslim, despite Muslims making up just 6 percent of the prison system.

In the even more extreme Guantanamo Bay prison, that number rises to 100 percent.

But it doesn’t end there, because the laws and policies of the war on terror have created a culture of fear — one that teaches American society to fear Muslims, and one that teaches Muslims to fear the U.S. government. While it’s gotten worse under Trump, it’s not something that started under him. The Bush administration built the violent infrastructure of the war on terror, Obama expanded it, and Trump is simply building on it still.

Earlier this year, President Trump signed two executive orders, commonly referred to as the Muslim Ban and Muslim Ban 2.0, which halted the issuing of visas to people from seven (and later six) majority-Muslim countries.

While many were surprised by this overt act of racism and xenophobia, the war on terror has taught Muslims like me that this is nothing new. The orders came amid a surge of hate crimes against Muslims, which recently reached their highest levels since 9/11 itself. Furthermore, the number of hate crimes this year has far surpassed that of 2016 — by 91 percent, according to the Council on American Islamic Relations.

“While the bias that motivates a hate crime may be unusual in its ferocity,” a Human Rights Watch report explained way back in 2002, “it is rooted in a wider public climate of discrimination, fear, and intolerance against targeted communities, which may also be echoed in or enhanced by public policy.”

As a Muslim American who has lived in the United States for most of my life, September 11 taught me a few things. It taught me that collective responsibility is at the heart of the laws and policies that have unfolded in the war on terror — that we’ll be targets till we prove we’re “good” Muslims who are uncritical of foreign policy and who believe in the American dream.

It taught me that religious freedom is a value that the United States cherishes, until of course Muslims try to claim it. Then it becomes a security concern.

It taught me that this is actually what many groups have experienced in our country. Different groups are targeted at different times under different umbrellas for our “national security,” which is nothing more than legitimized and institutionalized racism and xenophobia.

This year will mark 16 years of the war on terror — 16 years of military and militaristic means to allegedly abate the terrorist threat, but which have in fact terrorized my own community.

This year, as part of the DC Justice for Muslims Coalition, I’m leading a campaign called #MySept11MuslimStory to provide a space for Muslims to share their stories on the consequences they’ve experienced post-9/11 — not just from the U.S. government, but from society at large. This is my way of empowering the Muslim community to resist the oppression we’ve experienced on the basis of collective responsibility.

The war on terror was supposed to be about making our country safer. But as a Muslim American, I don’t feel any safer. Instead, I suspect those feelings of safety were never meant to be extended to me, or my community. As we prepare for what’s ahead, empowering ourselves couldn’t be more important.

*Maha Hilal, Ph.D., is the Michael Ratner Middle East fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies in Washington, D.C. She’s also a steering committee member of DC Justice for Muslims Coalition, an organizer with Witness Against Torture, and a board member of the DC chapter of the National Lawyers Guild.


Enjoy the article?

Did you find this article informative? Please consider contributing to Eurasia Review, as we are truly independent and do not receive financial support from any institution, corporation or organization.


 

FPIF

FPIF

Foreign Policy in Focus (FPIF) is a “Think Tank Without Walls” connecting the research and action of more than 600 scholars, advocates, and activists seeking to make the United States a more responsible global partner. It is a project of the Institute for Policy Studies.

3 thoughts on “War On Terror Has Targeted Muslims Almost Exclusively – OpEd

  • September 17, 2017 at 1:24 pm
    Permalink

    Perhaps Ms Halal is familiar with the proverb, “Physician, heal thyself,”?

    Reply
  • September 17, 2017 at 4:54 pm
    Permalink

    Dear Maha Hilal,
    I read your article hoping to find your unbiased opinion on why ordinary men and women should ask their governments to accept Muslims as equals.
    Ask the French who they fear on their streets, it is the Muslim Terrorist.
    Ask the English who they fear on their streets, it is the Muslim Terrorist.
    Ask the Spanish who they fear on their streets, it is the Muslim Terrorist.
    When an Imam leading a terror cell dies assembling a bomb, what does that teach the Spanish about the historical connection between Muslim radicalisation and killing of innocent men, women and children on the streets.
    Until the message of hatred of unbelievers found in the pages of the Koran is torn out, until the avowed intention of Muslim world domination is removed, there will always be distrust of the man and woman following the prophet of war, and not the Son of God, Jesus, the prophet of peace.(not the false god of the trinity, an abomination)
    I pray daily for a true righteous World leader, the return of Jesus Christ, the Jewish born Messiah, and for the peace he promised when all men and women will be encouraged to give the creator of all, His Holy Father, the glory that is due to him.

    Reply
  • September 18, 2017 at 6:14 pm
    Permalink

    The truth is that the contents of the Muslim “Holy Book” and the marshalling of its edicts into something called Shariah Law have made adherents of this ideology at odds with our Western civilization. Buddhists, Hindus, Atheists, Agnostics, Communists etc have no problem living in Western countries . Muslims do.

    We have thousands if not tens of thousands of Muslim immigrants or their children wanting to kill as many of us as they can, and millions of Muslim immigrants in sympathy with them . The Muslim slogan “Allah Akbar” now tends to imply someone is going to be shot at , or have his throat cut.

    And many Muslims who have not joined the terrorist club have been so imbued with the notion that all non-Muslim women and girls are whores that in Britain (and probably in the rest of Europe) they groom isolated schoolgirls as young as twelve to rape, traffic, pee upon, beat and torture. (In just own town, Rotherham in England, an official report found out that 1,400 English schoolgirls between the ages of 12 and 16 were victimized in that manner)

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CLOSE
CLOSE