Eurasia Review newsletter

Analysis

prev
next

Oil Find Reported In Arctic Sooner Than Expected

By Andrei Fedyashin Oil fever could strike the Arctic sooner than expected and is likely to be accompanied by a ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 32 | Comments

Read more

India Re-Calibrating Af-Pak Strategy

As the US seeks to pull out of Afghanistan and evidence of Pakistani collusion with the Taliban becomes clearer, India ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 40 | Comments

Read more

After Mubarak: Egypt And The Succession Issue

By Riad Kahwaji and Dr. Theodore Karasik All eyes are turning towards Egypt and who will succeed Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak. ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 53 | Comments

Read more

China's Climate Change Policy: Domestic And Global Implications

By D.S.RajanThe People’s Republic of China (PRC) deserves full credit for its pro-active approach towards combating global warming and climate ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 109 | Comments

Read more

India Misses Opportunity For Humanitarian Intervention In Gilgit-Baltistan

The Gilgit-Baltistan (GB) area of Pakistan-Occupied Kashmir (POK) was one of the first and worst to be affected by the ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 64 | Comments

Read more

The Upcoming Nalanda University

By P. K. GautamThe new Nalanda University now being planned to be rebuilt will soon provide momentum to the systematic ...

Analysis | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 81 | Comments

Read more

New Developments In Military Automation

As thousands of US soldiers leave the Iraqi battlefield, the US military ramps up efforts to increase unmanned and automated ...

Analysis | Wednesday, 1 September 2010 | Hits: 83 | Comments

Read more

Yet Another Great Game In Afghanistan: The US And China

By Sriparna PathakThe United Nations (UN) Human Development Report of 2009 rated Afghanistan as the world’s second most impoverished country. ...

Analysis | Wednesday, 1 September 2010 | Hits: 131 | Comments

Read more

Defining The Obama Doctrine, Its Pitfalls And How To Avoid Them

By Kim R. Holmes, Ph.D. and James Carafano, Ph.D. American Presidents become known for “signature” statements and responses to foreign policy ...

Analysis | Wednesday, 1 September 2010 | Hits: 106 | Comments

Read more
More in: Analysis

Iranian Social Networking, Hard-Line Style

AddThis Social Bookmark Button
By Golnaz Esfandiari
(RFE/RL) -- "The website of the followers of Khamenei has been created. Please enter with your hijab and after completing your ablution."
With that Facebook post, 29-year-old Iranian Ahmad heralded the arrival of a new social networking site, called Velayatmadaran, launched by the Iranian establishment.

The name is a reference to "followers of the velayat," or Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, and it's part of an attempt by Iranian officials to get in on the social-networking craze. Like other sites that have proved to be crucial tools for communication, discussion, and the exchange of news and information among members of the opposition -- including Facebook -- Velayatmadaran allows users to network and post pictures, videos, and articles.

Predictably, given his support for Iran's political opposition, Ahmad's status update, the messages that go out to Facebook "friends," became an immediate hit. There was an explosion of sarcastic comments from his friends. One wrote that he would join the website on condition that his friends promise not to tag him in pictures of President Mahmud Ahmadinejad and hard-line cleric Ahmad Khatami. Another mocked that "the networking site is a dream come true."

Iranian officials have smeared such social networkers as lackeys of Iran's enemies and victims of a "soft war" being waged against Tehran.

For his part, Ahmad thinks Velayatmadaran holds little attraction for young Iranians: "[The hard-liners] are losing their supporters from top to bottom. It's clear just from the name of the site that it is designed for their own supporters."

If You Can't Beat 'Em...

According to the "About Us" section, the site was launched to create an online platform for the religious hard-liners of Iran's Hezbollah to exchange ideas and fight "evil." Issues like "the rule of the supreme jurist" and "women and family" are up for discussion.

So far, the site has attracted some 3,000 members and includes posts of pictures of "Imam Khamenei," a reference that seeks to elevate the current supreme leader beyond his clerical status; articles about the teachings of ultra hard-line Ayatollah Mesbah Yazdi; and cartoons skewering the opposition Green Movement.

In the aftermath of Iran's disputed election in 2009, social-networking sites were filled with images and comments related to the protests over the reelection of President Mahmud Ahmadinejad. Despite official attempts to limit the free flow of information, word of the use of force by government forces spread quickly.

Velayatmadaran's creators write that "the enemy" has recently used social-networking websites for its own benefit and for "spreading lies." They say that while that same enemy has used the virtual world "skillfully" and social-networking sites as a "weapon," Hezbollah has relied on its "faith and correct belief." It's time to fight fire with fire, they argue.

Ali Honari, a 32-year-old sociology student who has been living and studying in Holland for nearly a year, sees little to attract Iranian young people.

He says the new website appears to be an attempt by Iranian authorities to funnel their supporters away from mainstream social networking or from engaging in open debate.

"A friend of mine who taught some courses at the Qom seminary said that even there, students are becoming increasingly modern," Honari says. "They have access to the Internet, they watch the latest movies. [The establishment] needs to make sure they remain loyal."

Toronto-based Iranian blogger Arash Kamangir says he doubts Velayatmadaran would attract many members.

"It's not difficult to launch a new social site," Kamangir says. "What is difficult is to attract members. [Iranian leaders] cannot do it, because they don't want to open these sites to those who are opposed to them and their supporters don't seem to be many."

He adds that Velayatmadaran looks suspiciously like a sort of "training camp" for hard-liners to gain familiarity with social-networking sites.

"They see it as a military camp where they can receive training," Kamangir says. "They say that the next steps will be to go out and take some [action]."

'Cyber War'

New York-based journalist Roozbeh Mirebrahimi, who was jailed in Iran in 2004 over his online writings, says the creation of Velayatmadaran and other similar moves -- such as the launching of hard-line blogs -- is the result of Tehran viewing the Internet as a threat.

"The Islamic republic and the security military organs that are behind such projects make a big mistake by thinking that online tools -- blogs and now social networking websites -- themselves have the power to influence," Mirebrahimi says. "It's a wrong belief, these are only tools -- the ideas that are being discussed within these tools are [what is] important."

The Iranian establishment has for years fought a cyber battle on several fronts. It has reportedly blocked and hacked websites, tracked activists online, and threatened Iranians who have turned to blogs and other online platforms to express themselves. It has prosecuted and jailed some people based on their online content.

But the Iranian establishment has faced fierce and determined opposition by activists and intellectuals, who have used proxy sites and antifiltering tools to bypass government censorship.

One web developer in Tehran, who spoke on condition of anonymity out of fear for his safety, says activists seem to be winning the cyber battle. "The government blocks [and] young citizens find a way to unblock the filtered website," he says. "They manage to spread the news the government wants to censor."

One Friday Prayers leader, Ayatollah Alam Ahdi, effectively acknowledged as much last week. He said during a public appearance in Mashhad that "the enemy" has occupied the virtual world, adding that the "cyber war" should be taken seriously.

"If, for example, we have inside and outside the country 10 million bloggers, 9.5 million of them are against Islam," he said.

He advocated using "any tool," even if contravened Shari'a, or Islamic law.

"In a war, anti-Shari'a [moves] are permissible; the same applies to a cyber war," Alam Ahdi said. "The conditions are such that you should fight the enemy in any way you can. You don't need to be considerate of anyone. If you don't hit them, the enemy will hit you."

Honari, the doctoral candidate studying abroad, says he thinks the Iranian establishment is fighting a losing battle.

"All the sites that are popular are sites where users can discuss and express their critical views [freely]," he says. "That's against the views and principles of an authoritarian regime. The Iranian government cannot use the Internet properly."

As far as Velayatmadaran goes, he says a critical dialogue is impossible.

"What would they do with someone like me with opposed views if I became a member?" Honari asks. "They would have to delete me over and over."

RFE/RL

Copyright (c) 2009. RFE/RL, Inc. Reprinted with the permission of Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 1201 Connecticut Ave., N.W. Washington DC 20036.

Add comment


Security code
Refresh

tumblr site counter

Opinion

prev
next

When Markets Fail

One of the great mantras of the modern economics profession is that markets know best, and that the ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 21 | Comments

Black Civil Rights Mafia Betrays Black America

I am a black man alerting my fellow Americans about a tremendous evil which is going on in our great ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 19 | Comments

The War Of Climate

Thermometer measurements show that the earth has warmed by about 1.4 degrees Fahrenheit since the Industrial Revolution, when humans began ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 39 | Comments

Qaddafi's Remarks On Preventing A 'Black Europe' Unacceptable

In the 41 years since Muammar Qaddafi seized power in Libya, he has earned himself a reputation for political views ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 55 | Comments

Interview With Lev Ponomarev

Russia-watchers are no doubt aware of the recent arrest of my good friend Lev Ponomarev. Lev is one of ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 34 | Comments

New Orleans, Mr. O And Mr. Go

Five years ago this week, a beast drowned New Orleans. Don't blame Katrina: the lady never, in fact, touched the ... Read more

Opinion | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 48 | Comments

More in: Opinion

Experts

Burning Down The US House Market

The howls of surprised economists were everywhere last week as the government reported on Tuesday that July had the sharpest single-month plunge in existing home sales on ...

Experts | Thursday, 2 September 2010 | Hits: 20 | Comments

Read more

Are The Millennium Development Goals Counter-Productive?

By Oladiran Bello The EU’s discourse on the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) remains unhelpfully inward-looking. Heavy on chest-beating reassertions of Europe’s unmatched development spending, the official rhetoric falls short on concrete ...

Experts | Wednesday, 1 September 2010 | Hits: 92 | Comments

Read more
More in: Experts

Latest comments