ISSN 2330-717X

Hanif Atmar: The Panic Button For Afghan Mujahedeen And Militia-Men – OpEd


As Afghanistan’s national security adviser continues to show his influence in the upper echelon of politics, feudal warlords are attempting to undercut that power, leveling false accusations against the politician.

Hanif Atmar has been in the center of Afghan politics and decision-making at the highest level in post-Taliban era. He served as the Minister of Rural Rehabilitation and Development (2002-2006), Minister of Education (2006-2008) and Interior Minister (2008-2010) during the Karzai administration. He was regarded as “the most competent” anti-corruption cabinet member in Afghanistan by western nations.

Atmar is one of the few technocrats at the highest level who rose to prominence solely through his leadership, management and effective strategy mindedness, while a majority of the rest of his fellow cabinet members were former warlords and had military power. Born in 1968, Atmar was also the youngest cabinet member in the period of 2002-2010.

Days after taking office as president of Afghanistan, Ashraf Ghani appointed Atmar as his national security adviser. This was one of the initial political appointments made by President Ghani. Even though technically an adviser has no executive authority, Atmar has made his presence felt by leading National Security Council meeting sessions. He is now President Ghani’s go-to person because of his understanding of the domestic, regional and international politics.

In his very first days as national security adviser, Atmar was tasked to sign the Bilateral Security Agreement (BSA) with the United States on behalf of Afghan government. That showed the elevated trust and reliance of President Ghani on him. His endeavors and opinions matter more than other National Security Council members, even the ones with much more executive authorities.

That has created animosity among other Afghan politicians, especially former warlords and former president Karzai’s loyals, against Atmar. For example, last year when Islamic State’s hostility emerged in Nangarhar besides that of Taliban, they killed many civilians and seized several areas. Zaher Qadeer, deputy speaker of Afghan parliament blamed Atmar for stirring those particular events of violence in eastern Nangarhar.

The reason behind Qadeer’s allegations was Atmar’s opposition to his use of force by his militias against ISIS on his own and beyond Afghan government’s subjection. Qadeer received financial support from Iran in order to thwart ISIS in Nangarhar. Atmar opposed Qadeer’s militia making, rightly so because further inclusion of Iran in Afghan conflict will elevate sectarian tension.

Atmar suggested that all anti-terrorism military operations be taken under the Afghan Security Forces’ supervision. He knew if being let loose, Qadeer could well create a strong militia group of his own besides the existing ones. Militias have historically posed threat to democracy and rule of law to all nations in the phase of post-conflict rehabilitation. Qadeer later reportedly apologized to Atmar during his visit to Nangarhar.

Jamiat-e-Islami, Dr. Abdullah’s political party, too finds it hard to get along with Atmar. Time and again they blamed Atmar for political upheavals and the expansion of havoc to northern Afghanistan. Recently, Jamiat criticized President Ghani and Atmar for gravitating and centralizing power into their own hands. Jamiat also said that Atmar is seeking support from Afghanistan’s international partners to create a presidential guard of 10,000 forces. Even though that is not officially confirmed and still remains a rumor, the presidential guard could well diminish Afghan warlords’ threat to the government and play a force vis-à-vis their militias. After the collapse of Taliban, Afghan warlords and militiamen have constantly challenged rule of law and effective governance. That guard, if formed, could be used to daunt warlords and refrain them from using military force beyond government subjugation.

Last month first vice-president, General Abdul Rashid Dostum’s convoy was attacked in Ghormach district of Faryab province. After narrowly surviving the attack, Dostum held a press conference and accused Atmar for plotting the attack. He also criticized Atmar for usurping authority he is not entitled to. Seeking common ground, Jamiat members took advantage of the opportunity and started supporting Dostum’s stance.

Hoping to decrease President Ghani’s faith in Atmar, a Northern Alliance loyal, Razaq Mamoon wrote an article theorizing a conspiracy that Atmar was recently planning a coup against President Ghani. That theory and other media propaganda were bogus and futile attempts to distance Atmar from the president.

First, this is technically impossible given Atmar’s professional background, he is a firm believer in democracy and institutionalization, and also he does not have any militia or military power that would support disobedience of that sort.

Second, President Ghani has never opposed with him over any national issue. Atmar has shown great temperament towards media and has never showed any angry or sentimental reaction toward the accusations and allegations, he never succumbed to any pressure. After all the media allegations, President Ghani conferred the highest state medal upon Atmar in return for his services to Afghanistan.

Atmar has not only been involved in domestic security policies, he has also proved his effectiveness in the expansion of Afghanistan’s regional and international diplomatic horizon. He was the main actor who helped President Ghani restore NATO’s trust in Afghanistan, after which consequently NATO in Warsaw summit in July of 2016 pledged $4 billion to Afghanistan until 2020. He has also been the major actor behind the peace deal with Gulbudin Hekmatyar, which was signed in September by President Ghani and Hekmatyar.

One thing Atmar’s foes have in common, is their bleak background of warlordism. They know that Atmar is Ghani’s top ally and strategist, and is in pursuit of creating an institution driven government and military, rather than individual driven system. This is the sole reason a majority of former warlords envy Atmar’s proposed policies and actions. They know there is no space for them in an institutionalized government.

*Samim Arif is a Fulbright scholar & studied Master in Journalism and Public Relations at Indiana University Bloomington. He can be reached at [email protected]

Enjoy the article? Then please consider donating today to ensure that Eurasia Review can continue to be able to provide similar content.

16 thoughts on “Hanif Atmar: The Panic Button For Afghan Mujahedeen And Militia-Men – OpEd

  • November 23, 2016 at 5:01 am

    Great artcle reflecting truth and commitment if Mr. Atmar. The warlords and their cruelty on the innocent Afghans will soon diminish God Wiling.

    • December 24, 2016 at 10:32 pm

      Warlord dustom was his communist
      Friend with his brutalies or Hakmatyar
      And tTaliban.
      Your also from same network

  • November 23, 2016 at 5:30 am

    With all due respect, I would very much wish the president of Afghanistan Dr. Ashraf Ghani to carry out a thorough objective review and stock takings of his own security and defense institutions, scrutinizing his high ranking officials who are at positions of trust and authority, in order to see for himself as to what is going on there. I suggest starting from his own office of the NSC, the one right under his chin. This will be highly appreciated by everyone who cares about Afghanistan and about your leadership.
    In my humble opinion the present state of affairs and level of discipline in most of the security oriented institutions, the sense of duty and responsibilities that are needed to succeed under the current difficult circumstances, and the degree of fulfilling their government obligations, are appalling. Nepotism; log rolling, pork barrel and horse trading are the order of the day. The best example of this is the office of the National Security Council of Afghanistan, led by Mr. Atmar who has turned the Office of the NC into a booty distribution center. They follow no principles and have no integrity. The government budget is being looted and being used in hatching plots against the leadership of Afghanistan with an attempt to impede the president’s progressive program and high image, with the hope of failing him through skullduggery and ultimately demonize him and even topples him from power. Instigation of top government officials against each other is being spawned here. Gn. Dostum, the first voice president of Afghanistan claimed the recent attack on him was also to be a plot by NSC. He has now been instigated against the president. According to many, the twice collapsing of Kunduz temporarily was also primarily to be due to the negligence or purposely let – go by the NSC. They are only bent on their own self vested interests and pursue a hidden agenda in collusion with foreign spy agencies. No one cares about the president’s vision, the national goals and the socio-economic transformations that the country badly need, that have been envisaged to be implemented by your government that are aspired by the people of Afghanistan, or the necessary security prerequisites to get the Afghan infrastructural projects up in running, or about the security concerns that must and need to be addressed efficiently and professionally, so that security is maintained in the country. Two years down the Unity government, there is no sign of a real change, the old whimsical, honorific, greed and power sharing based, and corrupt system of Karzai is still lingering and very much pervasive. There is no sign of reforms. The people of Afghanistan are eager to see a tangible positive change and not a continuity of the past corrupt and failed regime of Karzai. Unless something is done urgently about these unscrupulous officials, the state will fail. The people of Afghanistan will be disappointed once again who have put their trust in their president. They say with one voice.” What has happened to reforms? What has happened to meritocracy? What has happed to fighting against corruption in earnest? Where are the good governance and the rule of law?” These are all pre-requisites for bringing security to the country and you know all this perhaps better than anybody else in the world. Let’s not forget that reforms always start from top down and not the other way round.

    • June 8, 2017 at 10:50 am

      I can’t be more agree with you, people are tired and they want to see the change which is never happened. fight for corruption to just go after few powerless and low rank officials? fighting corruption to let people like Zakhilwal who were at the heart of Kabul Bank scandal out of hook? Fighting warlords by granting them more power and bringing Hekmatyar? Afghanistan has never suffered in the past 15 years as much as it suffered under the NUG with widen ethnic tensions, increased insurgency, increased presence of ISIS and high tolerance of the government towards the people who are regardless to human lives and civilian lives. People are tired of empty promises and they want to see the change they deserve and they want their government to uphold the rule of law, fight corruption, control ruthless warlords as well as some of those so called technocrats. Unfortunately people like Atmar do not believe in democracy and they use all their power to suppress democratic movements in whatever forms it takes.

  • November 23, 2016 at 5:30 am

    God bless Atmar.
    We pray for him.
    Love you Atmar.
    And I appreciate the writer also Everlasting.

    • December 24, 2016 at 10:35 pm

      God is not with friend of criminal like
      Evil Atmar

      • June 7, 2017 at 1:07 pm

        Do u have any evidence that he is criminal? If u have it submit it to the court or if u talking baseless and nonsense then sit ur bloody dirty mouth and do not accuse some one
        Hope u understand , oh u guys don’t understand because urcriminal minded traitors

  • November 23, 2016 at 5:34 am

    Atmar’s Coupe against President Ghani exposed and foiled
    Based on Sayeedi’s report

    What is going on under the pretext of jogging for power?
    Sixth November 16
    The following people (ex high-ranking government officials) were involved in the coupe:
    – Yunus Qanuni
    – Hamid Karzai
    – Asadulla Khalid
    – Dr. Yasin Zia
    – Besmilla Mohammadi
    – Muslim yar
    According to several secret sources pertinent to power players (power brokers) in Arg ( the palace) and its peripheries , a few days ago , a collective move for toppling Ghani from power was organized. Seizure of the Palace, was unilaterally organized by Hanif Atmat, the National Security Adviser to the President and was supported by Hamid Karzai, but foiled in the bud. The threat is still lurking in and around the Palace though (in the lobbies and corridors as well as streets around the place).
    Leaks of undisclosed reports by sources quoting officials still in power, revealed that Atmar had been planning a coupe to seize power ever since his appointment to the National Security Adviser by organizing a team. He brought the financial and political sources under his tight control and then the first thing he did was to appoint Akhtar Ibrahimi, (who comes from Laghman) his clan mate to the position of PPS. This scenario resembles and reminds us of that of Hafizulla Amin’s hodtilr move against Noor Mohammad Taraki. (fomer communist leaders of Afghanistan).
    He then organized a working group for the implementation of the white coupe and simultaneously launched a campaign of instilling hatred and detest against Ghani and Abdulla in the population.
    A new report shows that Atmar’s senior partners in the coupe were Yunus Qanuni, Asadulla Khalid, Mismulla Mohammadi, Fazul hadi muslemyar, Dr. Yasin Zia (Governor of Takhar), and former deputy NDS, Hekmat karzai and to a certain degree Omar daoudzai the remnants of former president Karzai. The slogan of this gang was to act urgently in the matter of the coupe. If failed in their efforts, they would brand it as efforts for attempting to resolve the tension between Ghani and Abdulla.
    Hamid Karzai hates Ashraf Ghani for being from Ghiljaee tribe.” He blessed the coupe and prayed in a very pleading tone for its success and the toppling of Ghani and Abdulla”, said the source.
    In the presence of the coupe, Atmar addressed them, triing to reassure them that he would be able to convince all Hiz-Islami party factions’ leaders (including Hikmatyar) as well as Hazrati Mujadidi and Pir Gillani and some other Pashtun politicians. He stressed that “these leaders will not defy his words”. Taliban’s benign leaders residing in Kabul such as Mulla Salam Zayif and Mulla Mutawakil are also in my control, he added.
    The job to lead and oversight of the Tajik and the Northern Alliance Resistance group leaders, was assigned to Yunis Qanuni. Tasking of every one’s mission was immediately put into action. Assadulla Khalid the former NDS head was assigned to persuade Sayaf to join in the coupe.
    Atmar had coordinated all this through contacts and with advice from Americans. He was able to convince them to a certain degree and they promised to provide a sum of 160 million US dollars to finance his proposal. The Americans had pledged and accepted this, provided the coupe is supported by most of the political mainstream and that they are in agreement with the proposal.
    The first project to start with, was a psychological operation on Dr. Ghani and Abdulla. The object of the project was to mentally subvert the two by creating sensitivities and differences between the two so that the cooperation between them comes to a standstill and fall in turmoil. This would ultimately lead to the removal of the CEO that would then allow them to intervene as the masterminds of the crisis to act in. Thus, they would call for an “Interim” government under the leadership of Atmar. Yunus Qanuni would act as his senior-minister to take charge in the new government. All this under the pretext of political and security crisis in the country and the terms of the office could be extended from time to time.
    The report also says that Asadulla Khalid too, was desirous to become the next president but later for some reasons gave up his whim and desisted from his demand. This caused the process to prolong for a few days and cause the delay. His mission to persuade Astad Sayaf into the couple had proved unsuccessful too. In contrast, Karzai had accepted the coupe outright.
    According to a source close to Salam Rahimi, head of Presidential Administration Office, US special envoy for Afghanistan and Pakistan had arrived in Kabul with 160 million dollars and wanted to make sure that in order for the whole movement to work he wanted to see some of the known officials and politicians . It was at this very time that President Ashraf Ghani discovered the secrets of the coupe through members of American lobbyist in Kabul, and freezes the program in its entire dimension.
    The failure of the white coupe has brought Atmar under suspicion and aggression by President Ghani who evicted him from his office contemptuously several times over. The President has so far failed in his attempt to remove him from office due to the intervention by the American and British diplomats keeping him in the office.
    Recently, President Ashraf Ghani, in a meeting at the palace, passed a satirical comment, by saying that there was no need to send students to study political science abroad to the US or Europe, while they can do so in Laghman province,( the birth place of Atmar).( He really meant the coupe, because the coupe was spawned mainly by the Laghmanies)
    According to another reliable source, the recent attack on Dustaum has also been conspired by the same group led by Atmar. Dustum assassination was also part of the coup agenda. Akhtar Ibrahimi had been tasked right from the outset to kill Dustum at an opportune time and no wonder why he was looking for someone to have as his dupty who could do the job.

  • November 23, 2016 at 5:58 pm

    It is a mere propaganda article in favor of Atmar. I am quite sure the author has very close relations with Atmar. If you don’t believe me, you can go through his recent email and telephone contacts. Afghans are used to do anything for money and a potential position in the government, and Samim Arif is no exception. As a student I can understand how desperate he is.

    • December 24, 2016 at 10:37 pm

      Great man
      Thanks for exploring realities

  • November 23, 2016 at 8:21 pm

    This is so partial and biased and is much more campaigning for a person. Where was Atmar During Soviet invasion of his country? where did he got insured and got disability? He was a member of the intelligence organization of the communist party. He came from London and has rise to power is very much suspicious. Nobody buy this notion that somebody can rise to power on merit and not connections in Afghanistan, especially connection with foreigners…

  • November 23, 2016 at 8:45 pm

    The Afghan people know very well who Atmar and Mujahedeens are. The writer of the article is too one sided- every thing is so positive about Atmar and he tris to blackmail a particular grope. Why did he not mention Atmar`s background under the Communis regime? Atmar was a brutal spy and killed many innocent students and poor believers. Only real support he got, is from security agencies in the west and region. Otherwise he could still be in UK! He has almost no sicial base, not even among pashtuns!

  • November 23, 2016 at 10:44 pm

    Mr.Atmar, president Ghani and his governing team are centered around the idea of Pushton’s being in power and control of all other ethnic groups of Afghanistan. Unfortunately, they’ve chosen the wrong path. If they truly believe in democracy they should not traffic the Persian speakers of Afghanistan way of speech or writing. They should not act as dictators and take the power in their own hands.

  • November 24, 2016 at 4:54 am

    This is biased and is much more of a campaigning for Hanif Atmar. Where was Atmar During Soviet invasion of his country? where did he get injured and got disable? He was a member of the intelligence organization of the communist party. Betrayed his Khad Dr Najeebullah government and moved to Pakistan. From pro Soviet khad to Western block MI6. Got recruited, studied and trained in UK. I agree with the comment above that Nobody buy this notion that somebody can rise to power on merit and not connections in Afghanistan. Getting funding and support from MI6, Iran, CIA, ISI Saudi intellligence And RAW are all equally footsoldiers. If you call it a crime that Haji zahir Qadeer is getting funding from Iran against ISIS in Nangarhar, our whole ANA and security apparatus are getting funded and consulted by the above mentioned nations. Our enemy’s enemy is our friend so if anyone helps to fight these terrorists and zombies in Afghanistan therefore, we will accept their assistance. The people can no longer wait for central command to authorize operations!!!

  • November 25, 2016 at 8:59 pm

    With due respect to all
    As far as we can to go through Afghanistan recent decade history, its revealed all those who came to power, they have had same supporter out of Afghanistan to getting support frame neighbors Nations.
    But mine point is some of them used the getting outsider support to destroy the Afghanistan and were dangerous and fatal as Mujaheddin and Taliban.
    We as Afghan people have to chose among worse and bad. If we compare these two mentioned above regimes with which they falsely called communist regime. the Dr. Najeebullah government would be more appreciated by the people of Afghanistan even Mujaheddin them self ar agree upon this.
    So every person who had any position in farmer Dr.Najeebulla government will be acceptable then those named Mujaheddin and Taliban regime, which Hanif Atmar is one of them.
    however he gets support frame other but never used his power against ordinary Afghan innocent people. this Politician which getting money frame other but make these innocent people as parapet to them self.These people have not any rational reason to fight him except having blaming whit no reason.
    Best regards

  • December 24, 2016 at 10:15 pm

    Who is Atmar,
    KGB trainee
    AFG intel no 6 branch VP
    Chang side to Peshawar
    ICRC worker
    ISI agent
    Karzai team
    MOI Minister dispatched Taliban to North AFG
    Supportered Taliban within Govermnent
    The worst personality in our country.
    CEO privet Compani contacrtor.
    Ghani adviser
    Hard core Pashtoonist Ghani decision maker
    Brutal background enemies of AFG and
    Anti other ethnic AFG citizens especially Tajiks
    Persian speaking
    Look Friendly with US and west but real enemies
    Of west.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.