Let Mohammed Rest In Peace – OpEd


By Joharah Baker

There is no point falling into the pit of countering the claims being made about the death of Mohammed Al Durra, the 12-year old boy from Gaza whose videotaped killing was seen around the world. The boy, crouching in fear behind is equally afraid father as bullets whizzed around them, was killed admittedly by the Israeli army. Later, the army recanted after investigating the tape, saying Durra was killed by Palestinian fire instead. Well now, Israel is changing its story altogether, saying he was not killed at all. In fact, he was probably not even wounded and the French channel that broadcast the footage and brought some pretty bad rap to Israel, had most likely filmed a charade.

The reason why I will not waste my time countering this claim is that even with the great lengths the Israeli government went to to prove that the boy was never killed, it could not provide any irrefutable proof that Mohammed Al Durra – who would be 25 now – is still alive. No pictures, no testimonies, no hospital or morgue officials giving statements to refute his death, have been provided. Only sketchy information about ‘poor quality footage’ and the fact that it seems as though the boy moved his arm after he had slumped over his father following the explosion.

My point is this: indeed, Mohammed Durra’s death was at least one of the catalysts that fueled the second Intifada, and thus, was an important event in the history of the Palestinians. However, more importantly – most importantly to me –is the fact that this is about a boy who died in sheer terror, with his distraught father futilely trying to shelter him from the barrage of bullets coming their way.

Mohammed Al Durra was a boy, with a life, a family and friends. He died a horrible death and now he is being made to die a second one. I did not know Mohammed or his family, but I can only imagine how awful it must be for them to read these claims now and feel the pain of losing their child all over again. If nothing else, this is disrespect for human life of the worst kind.

Some may postulate that the rehashing of the Durra case is a personal jab at the French cameraman who shot the footage, Charles Enderlin. Perhaps. But as a Palestinian who has seen the pain endured by numerous families who receive the horrible news that their sons or daughters have been killed by the Israeli army, my concern is for his family and for his memory. He should be left to rest in peace. If Israel has axes to grind with French journalists or with the international community for holding it accountable for its actions, then so be it. Israel is not lacking in the public relations department.

That being said, there is just one decent thing left to do. Leave Mohammed Al Durra and his memory alone.

Joharah Baker is a Writer for the Media and Information Department at the Palestinian Initiative for the Promotion of Global Dialogue and Democracy (MIFTAH). She can be contacted at [email protected]

Established in Jerusalem in December 1998, with Hanan Ashrawi as its Secretary-General, MIFTAH seeks to promote the principles of democracy and good governance within various components of Palestinian society; it further seeks to engage local and international public opinion and official circles on the Palestinian cause.

To that end, MIFTAH adopts the mechanisms of an active and in-depth dialogue, the free flow of information and ideas, as well as local and international networking.

One thought on “Let Mohammed Rest In Peace – OpEd”

  1. Unfortunately you’re ignoring some key facts…

    A. The cameraman who actually shot the famous footage was NOT Charles Enderlin, but a Palestinian guy living in Gaza City. Mr. Enderlin is a journalist with a French TV station who’s stationed in Jerusalem, and who was not even present there when the incident happened.

    B. For years now, there has been a legal battle between a French activist, Philippe Karsenty, and the TV station that aired the footage. Karsenty has proved MANY times that the whole story is a concoction, created by the same creative people who’ve been staging many “incidents” in the past, some of them have appeared in a “60 Minutes” segment few years ago. His excellent presentation can be seen here: http://vimeo.com/17226900

    C. Of course, it’s much easier to spread a false accusation, ignite the mob, cause violence, create an explosion of hatred in the Islamic world — then quietly admit later that it was actually “not exactly so”. The damage has already been done. The same thing happened in the Summer of 2002, when the Palestinians spread the lie of “500 civilians massacred in Jenin by the IDF”…. Many European media outlets swallowed it, condemning the “evil Israelis”… American media was more cautious, they suspected it to be a hoax. The UN later found it out to be a hoax…. But the damage was done, the Israelis were the inhumane villains — which is exactly what the Palestinian propaganda machine wanted to achieve.

    You know, you can’t lie to everybody, all the time. People get it after a while.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>