Argentina: Macri’s Hypocrisy – OpEd


By Jack Memolo*

A week after the heinous terrorist attack in lower Manhattan, which killed five visiting Argentine tourists, the country’s president Mauricio Macri traveled to New York City to pay his respects to the victims, as well as promote commercial investment in Argentina. Before placing a memorial wreath of white flowers on the spot where an Uzbek citizen struck the five friends with a rented truck, Macri gave a short eulogy for the deceased.

“This must make us defend our conviction of the importance of peace, and our commitment to peace” he said. Macri then addressed the importance of the fight against terrorism, and the need for effective interstate cooperation on the issue. But what was most striking about his short speech was the ending. “We want to be part of this battle (against terrorism) that we all have to face in this world for a peaceful coexistence, with love amongst all of us.”

Certainly we all can identify with this statement. Those who would commit such an act of senseless violence have no place in a society, which respects the beliefs and creeds of all people. Yet no one would have understood this truth more clearly than Santiago Maldonado. While protesting the inhumane treatment of Mapuche Indians in the Patagonia region of Argentina, Maldonado suddenly disappeared. His associates suspected foul play on the part of the Argentine authorities and paramilitary police, with whom Maldonado had allegedly last been seen. Such a disappearance has struck hard at the hearts of many Argentines, especially those who experienced the military dictatorship from 1976 to 1983, which kidnapped and later murdered upwards of 30,000 people.

Over two months after Maldonado had gone missing, on October 17th, his body was found dumped on a riverbank which had already been “searched” three times previously by authorities.

During the nearly 80 days period after Maldonado’s initial disappearance, President Macri was almost completely silent, even refraining from addressing the issue until over a month after Santiago had first been declared missing. Despite recently saying he was doing “everything possible” to help Maldonado’s family resolve the circumstances of his disappearance, Macri has shown little initiative.

While Maldonado disappeared after showing his public support for the rights of the indigenous Mapuche, what ultimately led to his death was love, but not the kind defined by President Macri. Maldonado stood with the Mapuche not because of religion, or race, or ethnicity, but because of a common sense of humanity. Maldonado was a martyr for human solidarity, and a victim of hatred.

If we are to truly live in a society where, as Macri said, there is “love amongst all of us,” then we must demand answers from him and decry the fact that he has shown little action despite his professed concern for Maldonado. In spite of words issued by the Argentine president that day, Macri’s brief record is not reassuring.

Justice will only be achieved once Macri’s actions match his words, which is why Macri’s appearance in New York must be dismissed as an act of hypocrisy. For a nation like Argentina, which has endured the squalor of the “Dirty War” and the disappearance of tens of thousands of innocent citizens, the President must be held accountable for suppression of protest. President Macri must stand, as Santiago Maldonado did, with the most vulnerable amongst us.

*Jack Memolo, Research Associate at the Council on Hemispheric Affairs

Additional editorial support provided by Larry Birns, COHA Director, and Eugenia Rosales Matienzo, Research Associates at the Council on Hemispheric Affairs


COHA, or Council on Hemispheric Affairs, was founded in 1975, the Council on Hemispheric Affairs (COHA), a nonprofit, tax-exempt independent research and information organization, was established to promote the common interests of the hemisphere, raise the visibility of regional affairs and increase the importance of the inter-American relationship, as well as encourage the formulation of rational and constructive U.S. policies towards Latin America.

One thought on “Argentina: Macri’s Hypocrisy – OpEd

  • November 14, 2017 at 1:49 am

    1st, the (NON-forced) dissapearance of Santiago wasn’t something the officialism could take an advantage from, rather quiet the opposite. 2nd Macri is not to blame for a rastafari (who’s been talked of as a related family member of Cristina Kirchner…that’s not,normal) dissapearing, neither Bullrich, at least completely, but the gendarme’s chief in charge of the repression of these “poor Mapuche ppl”, assuming your impression of them. 3rd, they’re not these bambi-like happy indians catching flowers on the hills with mean, diabolic militia hunting them down. These guys are the “RAM” (google it and re-edit your article, make us that favor), and are the same ppl making trouble at ex and soon to be chilean president Enrique Piñeira (2 countries getting sick of hibbi jibbies cutting national rutes and breaking the law? Guess who’s wrong..) And 4th, We know Macri is not the best, but he’s better than all the peronists who carried us from being a top 10 country to place 56th or worse economically, while talking blatantly about the poor and selling themselves as a reference of human rights ppl, when,in fact Peron himself was part of a coup d’Etat,collabored with the AAA, and the Kirchner themselves had many dissapeared ppl during their presidencies.

    So, Mr Jack Memo, How about you research a little more before writting something about my country or my ppl, uh?
    Take your work more seriously man..Leave the trashy leftist talk for another day and write something more convincing. I hope your boss ‘ll take note.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *