ISSN 2330-717X

Our Troops As Cannon Fodder – OpEd


By William A. Collins

Officials and partisans who promoted the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan early on favored “Support Our Troops!” as a rallying cry. The Pentagon propaganda machine even produced cute yellow magnets for our cars as Congress voted again and again to sustain those wars, all on our national credit card.

Meanwhile, the government did precious little to support the troops themselves. Basic personal and vehicle armor had to be arm-wrestled into the military budget.

But getting funding to prevent combat injury and death is a breeze compared to finding the money to repair injured brains or head off suicides. First of all, there must be an official admission that these problems exist at all. That’s painful for the government. Wars of conquest are most popular if they can be made to appear tidy, safe, just, and relatively cost-free.

Thus, it behooves commanders investigating non-combat deaths to dally as long as they can before begrudgingly classifying them as suicides. It’s also important to prop up every mentally injured soldier with drugs and to send him back to the front, rather than agreeing that he’s “wounded” and needs to be sent home for psychological treatment. Such injury statistics are intentionally made obscure.

So is the number of vets who get discharged for suffering “mental disorders.” This diagnosis means the government doesn’t consider them “wounded” and doesn’t have to treat them. They are then free to do battle with the Department of Veterans Affairs over the nature of their disability and their place on that infamous waiting list for treatment.

For many veterans, this kind of combat is just as grueling as fighting insurgents. Although the care itself is generally agreed to be fine, the ordeal to obtain it is often Kafkaesque. While the military can always find the money for new weapons programs, money for treatment is somehow always short. Destroyer budgets go on the credit card. Psychiatric care budgets must compete hand-to-hand.

Around 6,500 veterans commit suicide each year, driven by demons the rest of us prefer not to know about. Nightmares, sorrow, shame, and guilt can be self-reinforcing, especially when there is no one at home to share them. Plus, the effects are long-lasting. More Vietnam vets have now committed suicide than died in combat.

Female soldiers who become victims of sexual violence have it especially hard. The military tries to play down the number of rapes. Victims are often ignored, perpetrators are not prosecuted, and women who press their cases can find themselves diagnosed with a mental illness and discharged. And if the Department of Veterans Affairs is normally short of psychiatrists, you can imagine how fully staffed its OB-GYN departments are. Female deaths on duty are often attributed to ambiguous causes. Assault isn’t an acceptable category.

With the Pentagon’s emphasis on keeping all military engagements tidy, clean, and eminently worthwhile, it’s no wonder that real-life tragedies can get swept under the carpet. Suicide, homelessness, joblessness, jail, mental illness, Agent Orange poisoning, depleted uranium exposure, downsized benefits…they’re all simply collateral damage for our troops.

Meanwhile the war machine must keep filling its maw with new unsuspecting soldiers, using slick videos and shaky promises. Maybe all new recruits should have to sign their papers in a veterans’ hospital.

OtherWords columnist William A. Collins is a former state representative and a former mayor of Norwalk, Connecticut.

Click here to have Eurasia Review's newsletter delivered via RSS, as an email newsletter, via mobile or on your personal news page.

Other Words

OtherWords distributes commentary and cartoons aimed at amplifying progressive analysis in the national conversation. It empowers readers to become more engaged citizens.

One thought on “Our Troops As Cannon Fodder – OpEd

  • July 13, 2012 at 11:03 pm

    The situation described in this article is the result of a disconnect between US troops in active duty and the upper middle and wealthy classes of the population — the most effectively involved groups in national politics, whose sons and daughters seldom serve in the present ‘volunteer’ armed forces.

    Presently, the bulk of US forces involved in these foreign wars are recruited from immigrant and minority working-class families, who join out of despair in the absence of available civilian jobs in today’s outsource-based economy. Today’s US Armed forces are just one step from turning into a mercenary army.

    To those familiar with world history — both ancient and modern — this phenomenon is indicative of the final stages of all decaying empires — when money tries to replace the last vestiges of patriotism…


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.