Win Or Lose Trump Will Leave America A Divided Nation – Analysis


By Ankita Gothwal*

Republican Presidential candidate Donald Trump is building his political fortunes on growing schisms in American society through his sharply dividing claims on how he is going to make America “great again”, especially by walling the US borders to stop immigrants from entering the country. His political campaign has presented the threat to Americans at home and abroad from terrorism as a problem emanating solely from radical Islam; as a problem that is religious opposed to an ideological one. Even more surprisingly, a good proportion of the American population has emerged as a buyer of this divisive rhetoric, exposing the economic, social and political fault lines that exist in the US.

For the first time, terrorism, religion and ensuing divisiveness have churned such intense political bickering in any US election. The Trump and Hillary campaigns have divided America more sharply than ever before. There are various nuances in this overarching vote bank shift. The most visible have been the domestic considerations for supporting Donald Trump and the resultant respective internal dilemmas in both the Republican and the Democratic parties. This has, in turn, led to the change in the nature of voters and their criteria for casting the ballot.

Trump has unleashed a barrage of racial, anti-Islam, misogynistic and chauvinist slurs that anything but assure his credibility as a future President. Moreover, he has spelled out a confounding mix of opinions on the US’ future allies and the country’s economic and trade policies. His pandering to Russia has left foreign policy analysts, current establishment and practically most of the world wondering about the future of US-Russia relations. Speculations about the Trump-Putin rapport have further blurred the US’ foreign policy goals under Trump.

Recent numbers show that although Trump is trailing Hillary, his campaign is doing relatively well. However, sustaining Trump’s momentum is highly doubtful in the face of the sitting President’s criticism declaring him as ‘unfit’ to be the next President of the US; Hillary’s concerns about US’ nuclear future under a highly volatile and aggressive Trump as US President; and most surprisingly, in the face of the opposition that Trump faces from within the Republican Party. Trump’s campaign has weakened the Republican Party like never before, as probably this is the first time the Grand Old Party (GOP) is witnessing a prominent political shift to the Democratic Party’s candidate with open anti-Trump declarations coming from within the Party. Especially over the past few weeks, Trump’s divisive, anti-Islam political tone has been critically damaging for his campaign. His tirade against Captain Humayun Khan of the US army has fuelled a war of words with John McCain. Added to which, his disparaging comments about women, on race and the like have all managed to ensure that even the most conservative, staunch supporters of the GOP distance themselves from this Presidential hopeful and instead side the Democrat’s candidate.

Trump might end up on the losing side in the approaching November elections. However, many reckon that the damage is done. Regardless of whether Trump wins or loses, America might not be as tolerant a nation when it comes to issues of immigration, extremism and terrorism. A post-election America might witness a conservative backlash, the possibilities of which emerge in two facets. If Trump wins, we could see an increasingly aggressive opposition to immigrants, especially against those from Asia. This backlash might manifest at the level of a changing American psyche not only in private but in public places too. If Trump loses, these actions from Trump’s conservative supporters might not see an open display but a cognitive shift to a more pronounced xenophobia would stay and for long!

In either case, Trump’s support base has brought to the fore a section of Americans that was waiting for someone like Trump to tap their growing frustration with immigration, religious fundamentalism and most importantly, political correctness of Washington DC. However, his supporters have failed to assess his flip-flops, lack of coherence and his political incorrectness. There is a danger in reading the aforementioned Trumpian attributes as his feats; rather these are symptomatic of what could become of America should this man be chosen as the President of this country.

The most unfortunate part about the Trump campaign is that the divisive and hateful rationales that have been evoked have affected the entire world. While Hillary Clinton might not be the best candidate given her possible scandalous past but she stands tall in comparison to Trump, especially with her open accommodating approach to work towards integrating the country’s citizens as well as its immigrants.

The question that begs an answer is: what will become of the American cadre that would vote for Trump in the 2016 elections? In case he wins, the political hubris could turn into open xenophobia, but the clear and present danger is that even if he loses, the latent, simmering hatred will wait to tapped into by another Trump clone in the future.

*Ankita Gothwal is a PhD Scholar at American Studies Programme, School of International Studies, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi. She can be reached at: [email protected]

South Asia Monitor

To create a more credible and empathetic knowledge bank on the South Asian region, SPS curates the South Asia Monitor (, an independent web journal and online resource dealing with strategic, political, security, cultural and economic issues about, pertaining to and of consequence to South Asia and the Indo-Pacific region. Developed for South Asia watchers across the globe or those looking for in-depth knowledge, reliable resource and documentation on this region, the site features exclusive commentaries, insightful analyses, interviews and reviews contributed by strategic experts, diplomats, journalists, analysts, researchers and students from not only this region but all over the world. It also aggregates news, views commentary content related to the region and the extended neighbourhood.

3 thoughts on “Win Or Lose Trump Will Leave America A Divided Nation – Analysis

  • August 14, 2016 at 10:31 am

    I do not think Mr. trump will lose the coming election. He will win and will beat the neocon war criminal Secretary Hillary Clinton. It is true that she has massive support from the financiers, the industrial military complex, the oil industry, and the foreign policy establishment. But this triangular of militarism, oilism, and financiers has destroyed the US economy and has created the division in America between various social classes. Very few social groups living on this triangle have made huge wealth and others have paid the cost through unemployment, austerity, poverty, debt, growth and productivity stagnation, and high taxes. The Federal government fiscal policy has been restrictive but growing on militarism and imperialist wars that will never be won. The Fed monetary policy has created asset bubbles that have helped the financiers, generating huge returns for this group. Both policies have disintegrated the imperialist economy, creating huge social division. Mr. Trump has not created this division. Rather, Mr. Trump is using this social division for his political campaign. He plans to change this division and help the larger segments of the American people. He tries to have different foreign policy that is not based on wars and NATO imperialism. He tries to have better relations with many countries. He tries to destroy Daesh and he could. Daesh will disappear if Turkey closes its borders; fighters are prevented from going to Iraq and Syria; American weapons stop going to terrorists; and sanctions are imposed on countries financing Daesh and other terrorist groups. President Obama and Secretary Clinton cannot achieve these goals, because both are working for implementing the Israeli New Middle East Strategy. Both have failed and American people have decided to use other alternatives. If they cannot achieve what they aim, Americans will revolt under the neocon establishment headed by President Obama and Hillary Clinton and other neocon imperialist republicans. Once again, Mr. Trump has not created the division in America; Rather, it is globalized monopoly capitalism based on imperialism, wars, patriotism, state control, domination of the super-rich, expansionism, destruction of social fabric of other nations, destruction of the environment, racism, and domination of big business. This globalized monopoly capitalism has also impeded progress and development and just cannot fit with the new reality. It is time to go by the power of the American people.

  • August 14, 2016 at 4:02 pm

    This is coming from an “all American” writers am sure…haters be haters

  • August 15, 2016 at 1:20 pm

    Divided America? The current President and his two attorney generals, have set back the racial clock to 1968. It doesn’t help that his fo-radicalized spouse spews hateful comments like the “bedroom built by slaves…” Trump may or may not win, but he recognizes that virtually all politicians just want to keep their seat at the Hog Trough, and the average middle-class American voter realizes this. Hilary will probably win; unfortunately the ‘tuning of the email scandal by Bill and Lynch’ and the Director of the FBI’s refusal to tell the truth, suspend her clearance and continue the investigation reminds the average voter who will never get ahead of the reality of American power politics…one thing should be pointed out to the voters when she begins her ‘experience as secretary of state’ screed–everything she did was a disaster, from Benghazi to her emails connected with her and Bill’s ‘foundation’, to the worst–the Arab Spring, an initiative that backfired so badly it will take generations for us to restore trust in the Levant, particularly Egypt.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *