ISSN 2330-717X

Can State Bank Of Pakistan Dare To Follow The US Federal Reserve? – OpEd

By

The Federal Reserve of United States has cut rates in an emergency that has created opportunity for other central banks around the globe to cut rate, especially for those who held off so far out due to domestic and external concerns. It is expected that State Bank of Pakistan (SBP) will also follow the suite. However, many analysts expect the SBP to opt for status quo in the upcoming monetary policy announcement. There are indications that inflation rate is easing in Pakistan, many attribute this to high base effect, delay in utility rate adjustments and price normalization in certain food categories rather than genuine price declines across the basket. It is also feared that if the central bank opt for cut in policy rate, Pakistan may experience reversal in the influx of ‘hot money’. There are ample evidences that the reversal has already started.

According to some analysts, Pakistan being less integrated with the global supply chains has historically remained largely insulated from the impact of ‘black swans’. Given limited financial integration with the globe, the country’s monetary policy setting has also remained more inward looking, dominated by domestic factors (inflation and domestic growth). Even in last two major instances (Dot-com bubble and Subprime mortgage crisis), when Fed opted for emergency rate cuts and subsequently EM/FM central banks went on an easing spree, Pakistan either maintained or hiked interest rates catering to the domestic need for tightening monetary policy. They also highlight that the comparison with the past may not hold now, since the situation has changed.

If history is any guide, an emergency rate cut by the US Fed generally triggers policy response from other central banks across the world, albeit the response varies in proportionality depending on domestic factors and impact of the event on a certain country. The policy response from the central banks is relatively quick and larger in scale when the economic repercussions of the event are more global. A review of 2007-08 financial crisis indicates that emerging market central banks kept their monetary firepower unused until the late 2008, when the severity increased and its impact started spilling over to global markets despite Fed being in action since late 2007, (Fed had cumulatively slashed interest rate by 425bps in a year). 

The same is true in case of the Fed’s emergency rate cuts in the wake of the tech bubble and the 9/11 attacks. Taking cue from the past, it is anticipated that coronavirus has become a global pandemic and that too happening in a more interconnected world – should move central banks into action. The move has already started happening, though on a swift scale.

The US Fed announced a substantial half percentage point interest rate cut, bringing the target range for Federal Funds rate to 1.0-1.25%. The unanimously voted decision came in response to emerging risks to economic activity from the virus outbreak. The move followed the G7 group’s pledge to use ‘all appropriate policy tools’ to counter the adverse economic impact of Coronavirus. The Fed’s decision has set the ball rolling for other central banks across the world. The easing spree has already started, with the Australian and Malaysian central banks announcing rate cuts (25bps each) in their recent monetary policy announcements. Bank Indonesia earlier last month announced a rate cut of 25bps. The Bank of Canada cut its benchmark rate by 50bps; making it the 5th central bank to announce easing following global peers. With talks of a coordinated policy response making the rounds, attention will shift towards European Central Bank and Bank of England scheduled to announce monetary policies later this month. 

The US Fed reduced interest rates by another 100bps on Sunday. The emergency is evident because the announcement came of a holiday. Therefore, there is even pressure on SBP to cut interest rate by minimum 200 bps. Analysts are of the view that convincing IMF should not pose any issue. The lender of last resort should be a little more considerate towards Pakistan. 


Thanks for reading Eurasia Review. For more of our reporting make sure to sign up for our free newsletter!

Shabbir H. Kazmi

Shabbir H. Kazmi

Shabbir H. Kazmi is an economic analyst from Pakistan. He has been writing for local and foreign publications for about quarter of a century. He maintains the blog ‘Geo Politics in South Asia and MENA’. He can be contacted at [email protected]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.