ISSN 2330-717X

Burma: Three Men Given Death Sentence For Murder That Sparked Riots


By Hanna Hindstrom

The three Muslim men accused of raping and killing Thida Htwe – the Arakanese girl whose death sparked sectarian violence across Burma’s Arakan state this month – were sentenced to death by the District Court in Kyaukphyu in western Burma on Monday, according to lawyers.

Htet Htet (also known as Rawshe), Mahmud Rawphi (aka Hla Win) and Khochi (aka Myint Swe) were found guilty of raping, murdering and robbing Thida Htwe from Thabyaychaung village in Ramee Township on her way home from a sewing lesson on 28 May 2012.

Lawyers said the court heard testimonies from eight people, including Thida Htwe’s brother, in a trial that lasted less than two weeks. Htet Htet, accused of masterminding the plot, committed suicide in jail last week, but was handed the sentence posthumously in accordance with Burmese criminal law.

Thida Htwe’s controversial death unleashed long-simmering religious and ethnic tensions in Burma’s westernmost Arakan state this month, starting with the violent murder of ten Muslim pilgrims by an angry mob in the state capital Sittwe. It culminated in the country’s worst sectarian riots in decades, which has left at least 50 people dead, thousands of homes destroyed and more than 32,000 people displaced.

The violence has also thrown a spotlight on the plight of the stateless minority group, the Rohingya, who are denied citizenship by the Burmese government and widely despised within Burmese society. Analysts say the riots represented a “symptom” of festering tensions and a state-sponsored policy of discrimination.

The verdict has brought mixed reactions in line with the increasingly polarised debate on the ongoing violence. Ba Shein, People’s Parliament representative in Kyaukphyu township commended the police force for its quick work.

“It is lucky to have this case solved in such a short period of time otherwise there would be other unwanted problems. They managed to arrest the culprits, seize evidence and hear witness accounts within about 10 days after the crime was committed – I would congratulate the police force their hard work.”

Many social media commentators have again responded to the verdict by lashing out against the Rohingya.

Meanwhile, human rights groups have expressed concern about both the speed and the legitimacy of the trial. “We condemn the imposition of the death penalty in all cases as cruel and inhumane treatment,” Phil Robertson, head of Human Rights Watch Asia division told DVB. “But we’ve also had no access to information about this case so there is no way to say whether the three men on trial are in fact guilty.”

“My concern would be whether there was any kind of proper judicial system,” added Chris Lewa, Director of the Arakan Project. “This was quite quick, so it seems like a move to try to calm the Rakhine population.”

She warned that the ruling might spark further unrest in Northern Arakan state, where reports are surfacing of mass arrests of young Rohingya men by state authorities since the fighting ebbed off on Friday.

“There is no longer communal violence in Maungdaw, this is state sponsored violence,” she said. “The situation has gotten really bad. The army and NaSaka have been conducting mass arrest of young Rohingya males. Some people have seen them transported in trucks in handcuffs and blindfolded and the worst is that no one knows why.”

She added that hundreds of young men have been trying to cross the border to Bangladesh, but most are being turned away. The Bangladeshi government continues to block refugees from fleeing the violence in Northern Arakan state, despite growing international pressure to let them in.

The sectarian violence has become a crucial litmus test for President Thein Sein’s reformist government. Last week, democracy icon Aung San Suu Kyi underscored the need for “rule of law” to address the violence, but faces accusations of sidestepping the Rohingya issue.

Robertson said that those involved in the mob attack that left ten Muslims dead in early June must also be brought to justice by authorities in order to avoid accusations of double standards.

The two sentenced men have seven days to appeal the ruling, but the case still needs to be presented to the Supreme Court for a final decision.

Click here to have Eurasia Review's newsletter delivered via RSS, as an email newsletter, via mobile or on your personal news page.

Democratic Voice of Burma

The Democratic Voice of Burma (DVB) is a non-profit Burmese media organization committed to responsible journalism.

One thought on “Burma: Three Men Given Death Sentence For Murder That Sparked Riots

  • June 18, 2012 at 11:37 pm

    Stoking the fire!!!

    It is high time the international community stop their drool and look the Junta for what it is.

    No one has and would argue that the Rohingya, oppressed unfairly as they are, are saints but the way they are treated now, they would certainly become martyrs.

    Since that fateful day Aun San Suu Kyi gave her green light, the international community has been busy sucking up the the same horrid military as saints full of praise and red carpets all over the world for the sake of a piece of action on business/resource openings.

    But along with the grovling, those acts do give approval of just about every thing the military has been doing in the last one year including, but not limited to, most horrendous torture, rape and killing as well as displacement of hundreds of thousands of people in Kachin area, increasing land grabbing and conscription of underage children to make up large number of casulties in all the terror campaigns.

    In some sense, this current “west of Burma” crisis happens because of increasing financial difficulties for populace in general as well as hightened level of racism and chauvinism among the Burmese populace aping the military who are the epitomy of both now well accepted and praised by the “West”.

    About time the intetrnational community starts looking at their own acts, regardless of their regard for Aung San Suu Kyi who has been thoroughly supportive of the military thus far.

    Ther is always a danger that Rohingya would change the angle to all out Burmse Muslim affair.


Leave a Reply to Ohn Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.