Record US Gasoline Exports Do Not Appear To Be Driving Gasoline Prices – Analysis
(EIA) — The increase in U.S. petroleum product exports has garnered significant attention lately, as U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) data showed the United States was a net exporter of petroleum products (petroleum and other liquids, excluding crude oil) for the first time since at least 1949. The rise in U.S. product exports at a time of rising domestic product prices has led some to ask if higher gasoline exports might be causing higher gasoline prices. However, the available evidence does not support such a linkage.
Increased product exports have allowed Gulf Coast refiners an outlet for their production, which may have been reduced without this outlet. With the summer driving season approaching, this edition of TWIP will focus on gasoline exports. In 2011, total gasoline exports only comprised 18 percent of total U.S. petroleum product exports. However, they have been a growing share of total petroleum product exports since 2007 when their share was just 10 percent. The United States exported more than 500,000 barrels per day (bbl/d) of gasoline in 2011; this level represents a 57 percent increase compared to 2010, and a 266 percent increase compared to 2007. These increasing gasoline exports have been a response both to weak domestic demand and coproduction of gasoline spurred by strong global demand for distillate fuels.
The United States has always been tied into the global petroleum product markets, but this export growth has transformed its position from a net petroleum product importer into a net petroleum product exporter in short order.
In terms of gasoline, the United States remained a net importer for 2011 as a whole; however, on a monthly basis, it was a small net exporter by the end of the year. In addition to gasoline exports, the United States exported about 850,000 bbl/d of distillate fuel in 2011. With distillate crack spreads regularly exceeding those for gasoline in recent years, refiners have tried to maximize distillate production to capture this value. In doing so, they have also produced more gasoline. Thus, excess gasoline in Gulf Coast markets has been partly the result of refiners responding to distillate crack spreads.
Most of the U.S. exports for distillate and gasoline come from the Gulf Coast. Gulf Coast excess capacity has resulted from both declining demand (preliminary data for 2011 show gasoline consumption 550,000 bbl/d, or 6 percent, lower than 2007) and increasing capacity, such as the recent expansion at Marathon’s Garyville refinery in Louisiana. In addition, Gulf Coast refineries have a competitive advantage in some world markets. The Gulf Coast refining complex as a whole is very sophisticated. Refiners there have invested significantly in bottoms upgrading capacity and can thus run relatively cheaper crude oils. Moreover, they use natural gas for their fuel, which at current prices is an advantage compared to refineries fueled by petroleum. Gulf Coast refineries also have good water access and a location that allows for a relatively short-haul voyage to the growing Latin American markets.
Gasoline statistics at the national level can mask substantial geographic market variations for this product. Historically, the U.S. market has relied extensively on gasoline imports for supply. This has been especially true on the East Coast which has been the destination of about 85 percent of total U.S. gasoline imports. U.S. suppliers on the East Coast see imports as an economic way to meet domestic market needs. East Coast markets can be supplied by imports from areas such as Europe, where a relative over-supply of gasoline means wholesale prices there tend to be low. This creates a fairly consistent incentive to pull gasoline from Europe to New York Harbor.
So why do Gulf Coast refineries export product rather than send more to the East Coast, especially the Northeast, which receives much gasoline import volumes? Both pipeline capacity and domestic waterborne shipping constraints currently discourage increased volumes from traveling from the Gulf Coast to the East Coast. As long as European and other gasoline supplies remain competitive, the East Coast will continue to draw on these supplies. Additionally, expanded Midwest refining capacity is backing out requirements to ship products from the Gulf Coast north to that area.
At the same time, demand for gasoline in Latin America has been growing. Mexico has always been a major market for U.S. gasoline exports, but the volumes sent south have grown in recent years. Consumption in Mexico has increased 5 percent (38,000 bbl/d) since 2007 and 25 percent (160,000 bbl/d) since 2004. Furthermore in 2010 and 2011, gasoline production from Mexican refineries declined. From 2000-2007, total U.S. gasoline exports averaged about 150,000 bbl/d, and of that, Mexico made up about 110,000 bbl/d. Since 2007, exports have grown by 380,000 bbl/d, with 220,000 bbl/d of this growth going to Mexico, and an additional 130,000 bbl/d going to other countries in Central and South America, notably Brazil, Ecuador, Guatemala, and Panama (Figure 1).
Growth in U.S. gasoline exports does not itself translate into higher prices for U.S. consumers. Rather, export markets are providing an outlet for refiners who would otherwise have faced margins that incentivized run cuts, or possibly even shutdowns, as decreased domestic demand had created excess refining capacity.
The continuation of this export trend is by no means assured over the long term. Given most of the U.S. export growth has been to Latin America, if demand in that region slows, or if refining capacity in those countries is built to meet demand growth, fewer petroleum products could flow south in the future. Continued gasoline exports also depend on what happens domestically. If constraints to moving more gasoline from the Gulf Coast to the Northeast are relieved, the most economically efficient destination for Gulf Coast gasoline could be the Northeast, rather than abroad.
Gasoline and diesel fuel prices keep climbing
The U.S. average retail price of regular gasoline increased 3.8 cents this week to reach $3.87 per gallon, 31 cents per gallon higher than last year at this time. The Rocky Mountain regional average price increased more than 13 cents for the third consecutive week to reach $3.62 per gallon, but remains the lowest in the Nation, as it has been since the beginning of the year. The West Coast price saw the smallest increase, up less than 2 cents to $4.23 per gallon. The Midwest price increased about 3 cents to reach $3.84 per gallon, and the Gulf Coast increased about 5 cents to $3.70 per gallon. Rounding out the regions, the East Coast price moved up about four cents to reach $3.81 per gallon.
The national average diesel fuel price increased about two cents to $4.14 per gallon, 24 cents per gallon higher than last year at this time. The largest increase came in the Rocky Mountains, where the price increased a nickel to reach $4.12 per gallon, and the West Coast price was up a penny to $4.43 per gallon. The Midwest price was up a little more than two cents to reach $4.04 per gallon and the Gulf Coast price rose 1 cent to $4.05 per gallon. Finally, the East Coast price was up 1.5 cents to $4.18 per gallon.
U.S. average residential heating fuel prices show little change during the last week of the 2011-12 heating season
The U.S. average residential heating oil price increased by less than 1 cent per gallon during the week ending March 19, 2012, to $4.11 per gallon. This price is 23 cents per gallon higher than the last price reported during the 2010-11 heating season. The average wholesale heating oil price increased by 2 cents per gallon over the same period to $3.39 per gallon, 24 cents higher than the last price reported during the 2010-11 heating season.
The average residential propane price increased by less than 1 cent during the week ending March 19, 2012, to a price just shy of $2.87 per gallon, 1 cent per gallon higher than the last price reported during the 2010-11 heating season. The average wholesale propane price decreased by almost 8 cents per gallon to $1.24 per gallon, nearly 16 cents below the last price reported during the 2010-11 heating season.
This is the last data collection for the 2011-2012 State Heating Oil and Propane Prices (SHOPP) season. The start date for the next heating season will be on October 1, 2012.
Propane inventories post a build
As the mild winter tapers off, propane inventories have started to level off and turn upwards. Last week, total U.S. inventories grew by 0.5 million barrels. The Midwest region added 0.6 million barrels, and the Gulf Coast region grew by 0.3 million barrels. Meanwhile, the East Coast inventories dropped 0.3 million barrels and the Rocky Mountain/West Coast stocks were down by less than 0.1 million barrels. Propylene non-fuel-use inventories represented 10.5 percent of total propane inventories.