Switzerland: Call For Tougher Penalties To Combat Crime Rise


By Sophie Douez

The government is being called on to tighten the law to deter repeat criminal offenders following revelations of a six per cent crime increase nationally last year.

According to the Federal Statistics Office, cases of theft increased nationally by 16 per cent. However, despite the overall rise in crime in 2011, the number of minors charged with criminal offences was down by 21 per cent, while violent crime dropped by seven per cent and sex crimes were down by three per cent.

Cantonal statistics also released on Monday show border regions in the west of the country were particularly affected by crime such as pickpocketing, burglary, car-theft and bag snatching.

In a joint statement, the police ministers of cantons Vaud and Geneva said the penal code should be adapted to act more as a deterrent to repeat offenders. They also called on the government to support cantons by signing asylum readmission accords to facilitate the expulsion of troublemakers.

“[We] have noticed that our cantons are particularly exposed in relation to cross-border crime and offences committed by people without a valid visa,” police ministers Isabel Rochat of Geneva and Jacqueline de Quattro of Vaud said.

“[We] would like the federal authorities to look without delay at the scale of penal sanctions. Some are not adapted to the evolution of criminality and do not have a necessarily dissuasive effect on offenders.”

Joining forces

Rochat and de Quattro said that in response to rising cross-border crime, collaboration between police and security forces would be intensified.

They also called for more intensive discussions with the government on the engagement of border guards in fighting cross-border crime.

In canton Geneva, home to the European headquarters of the United Nations, local crime rose 18 per cent to 72,821 offences compared with 2010 – a total significantly more than the national rise.

Although violent and sexually related crimes were down nine and seven per cent respectively in the canton, cases of theft rose 29 per cent with burglaries up 17 per cent – up to 50 a day – pickpocketing up 43 per cent, bag-snatching up 28 per cent and car theft up 45 per cent.

A similar story was reported in neighbouring Vaud where robberies jumped 34 per cent and cases of pickpocketing skyrocketed by 103 per cent on 2010.

“These statistics are worrying. The current situation is unacceptable and I’m no longer prepared to tolerate it,” Rochat told reporters on Monday.

“The burglary phenomenon doesn’t just affect Geneva but the entire Lake Geneva region including France,” Geneva police chief Monica Bonfanti told swissinfo.ch.

Foreign nationals

Across the country, offences under the law on foreign nationals – which covers offences such as illegal entries and stays – rose ten per cent. The statistics office said this was due to a 15 per cent rise in the number of illegal entries or people staying in the country without a valid visa.

Closer analysis shows that Geneva has a specific problem with some 400 repeat-offenders from North Africa who are asylum-seekers with temporary residence, whose application has been rejected or who are illegal immigrants.

Geneva police said they were responsible for 32 per cent of pickpocketing and 40 per cent of bag-snatching cases.

“Today we face three phenomena: gangs from the Balkans, in particular Romania, who were responsible for a wave of burglaries last autumn and young Roma from the Balkans based in Milan who carry out burglaries between Italy and Paris,” said François Schmutz, head of Geneva’s criminal investigation department.

“This is difficult to combat as they are mostly minors and reinsertion measures are badly adapted. The third is citizens from North Africa who have settled illegally in Geneva who were initially very active in street crime and who continue to be active but have been strengthened with the arrival of people following the Arab Spring and have started to get involved in burglaries.”


Meanwhile, cantons in the eastern part of the country recorded similar statistics to the national figures. Police in canton St Gallen reported car theft rose 116 per cent in 2011, although overall crime rates remained steady year-on-year at 28,532 offences.

Crimes committed by minors declined from 1,070 in 2010 to 1,003 in 2011 in St Gallen, where the crime rate came in at 49 crimes per 1,000 inhabitants compared with a national average of 71 per 1,000 people.

Basel City reported an 11 per cent increase in crime under the penal code, with cases of theft accounting for 73 per cent of offences. In a departure from national statistics, violent crime increased eight per cent.

In canton Schwyz, overall crime declined 5.5 per cent to 6,240 offences with the number of crimes committed by minors declining 14.3 per cent. Theft increased by 161 cases, or 12.1 per cent to 1,480 offences.

(With input from Simon Bradley)


swissinfo is an enterprise of the Swiss Broadcasting Corporation (SBC). Its role is to inform Swiss living abroad about events in their homeland and to raise awareness of Switzerland in other countries. swissinfo achieves this through its nine-language internet news and information platform.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *