Is Trump A Paper Tiger Or A Sensible World Leader? – Analysis


The world painstakingly held its breath when the IRGC downed the sophisticated American drone (RQ-4A Global Hawk) with a price tag of US$ 110 million with an equally sophisticated Iranian surface-to-air missile Khordad-3 with a range of 75 kilometers in the Persian Gulf.

Immediately, everyone feared an American retaliation and ultimately the beginning of yet another unfortunate and deadly cycle of Middle Eastern violence that would create so much havoc in an already unstable region by disrupting firstly oil routes pushing prices up and causing chaos in the Gulf region and possibly in Israel if proxies got involved in the fighting.

And while the Americans argued that the drone was shot down while in international airspace, the Russians2 contradicted Trump administration by saying downed US drone was in Iranian airspace and so did the Iranians.

Nick Paton Walsh argues, in an analysis for CNN, that the incident shows that a war with Iran is not going to be an easy task or a basic “cakewalk:”3

“While America’s military is by no means threatened in the long term by Iran, instances like the downing of the drone show that Tehran can sometimes have an outsized effect with narrowly-focused efforts, and is an adversary certainly capable of keeping its opponents off balance. The US would win any conventional conflict in the short term, but should be wary that Iranian ingenuity (or deviousness, if you’re in Washington) will stop any conflict from being a “cakewalk.””

Once the dust cleared, it turns out that the military capabilities of Iran are quite formidable and that it has the strength and the might to take on the US, Israel and their Arab allies.

In this regard, Farnaz Fassihi and David D. Kikpatrick pointed out that IRGC exulted in the downing of the American drone with a feast and a prayer4:

“Seated on the floor of a villa in northeast Tehran around a tablecloth spread with platters of saffron chicken and rice with barberries, about 30 officials of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps and guests gathered Thursday night for a prayerful celebration.

“A special blessing for the commander who ordered the attack on the American drone and for the fighters who carried it out,” a preacher declared, as recalled by one of the guests present, who said a raucous chorus of “amen” arose from the room.

Their success earlier that day at shooting down an unmanned American Global Hawk surveillance drone (list price $131 million) surprised even some leaders of the Revolutionary Guards. They had wondered themselves whether they could hit an American target so high in the sky, according to the guest.”

A fistful of minutes before the American retaliatory strike, Trump called off the military operation on the grounds that it was not proportionate because it was going to lead to the death of 150 people when the Americans lost only an unmanned aircraft, after all. One wonders, however, if Trump is putting world peace first instead of America or has he taken such a hard and painful decision, for his pride and ego, because of other unrevealed motives?

….On Monday they shot down an unmanned drone flying in International Waters. We were cocked & loaded to retaliate last night on 3 different sights when I asked, how many will die. 150 people, sir, was the answer from a General. 10 minutes before the strike I stopped it, not….

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) June 21, 2019

….proportionate to shooting down an unmanned drone. I am in no hurry, our Military is rebuilt, new, and ready to go, by far the best in the world. Sanctions are biting & more added last night. Iran can NEVER have Nuclear Weapons, not against the USA, and not against the WORLD!

— Donald J. Trump (@realDonaldTrump) June 21, 2019

Motive 1: Avoid Incensing Iran

An American war on Iran with the help of Israel and the Gulf States would probably weaken this country but not destroy it because the latter will rely on its strategic depth and on the Revolutionary Guards to sustain the regime and an injured Iran would be deadly for the region, in the long run, after all. Consequently, Israel and the Gulf States would have to live in the fear of retaliation, ever after. Besides, a weakened Iran would, at all cost, want to develop a nuclear capability to defend itself in an adverse environment and nobody would be able to stop it, worse its drive would look quite legitimate.

Motive 2: Unleash The Deadly Fire Of Proxies

An all-out war of the US on Iran would ultimately mean an all-out war of proxies on allies of America in the region. Hezbollah and Hamas will strike, with might, the Jewish State, creating much chaos all over the country. The Houthis will target Saudi Arabia successfully with missiles and drones, and they have proved recently that they can achieve that with much success. The Shiites of Iraa would strike Bahrain and Kuwait, if need be, and the whole region will be in total upheaval and war tremors would probably have worldwide effect.

Motive 3: Kick-Starting Anew Moribund World Terrorism

So far Iran has kept a world course free of terrorism but in the case of an American aggression with the help of Israel and Gulf allies, it would instruct its own sleeping organizations, worldwide, to step into action and undertake terrorist actions against American, Gulf and Israeli interests. Worse, ISIS and Al-Qaeda will join the fray and cause as much trouble as possible and the whole world will become a war zone and not only the Mideast.

Motive 4: Push Iran Into Arms Of Russia And China

An American war on Iran would push further the latter to align itself with Russia and China and other eastern countries that are unhappy with Trump’s world policies and they could in the future found a front to counter America’s arrogance and expansionism.

Motive 5: Avoid War When America Is Gearing Up For 2020

Calculating Trump would not want to commit America to another global war in the Middle East which he could only win with thousands of troops on the ground and sending troops and suffering high casualties during an election year is synonymous of political suicide. This possible war would be a gift on a silver platter to the Democrats to win the presidential elections and Trump is clever enough not to offer them this golden opportunity to oust him.

Having said this, probably, then, one can say that Trump is not a sensible world leader but a calculating president who does not want to venture in the wild in spite of the pressure of hawkish Bolton and Pompeo.

So What Is Going To Happen Next?

Trump will continue putting pressure diplomatically and financially through ineffectual sanctions on Iran with the hope to bring the officials to the negotiating table, but the chance is that his approach will lead to failure as it did with North Korea and surely the Democrats will use this in the upcoming elections of 2020 and this might be a probable cause of Trump’s failure in his reelection bid, after all.

Undoubtedly, Iran is the winner of the present face off and the psychological effect of this will embolden the country to move forward to acquire the nuclear weapon in the next few years and, in the face of this, Trump will come out as a mere paper tiger.

You can follow Professor Mohamed CHTATOU on Twitter: @Ayurinu



Dr. Mohamed Chtatou

Dr. Mohamed Chtatou is a Professor of education science at the university in Rabat. He is currently a political analyst with Moroccan, Gulf, French, Italian and British media on politics and culture in the Middle East, Islam and Islamism as well as terrorism. He is, also, a specialist on political Islam in the MENA region with interest in the roots of terrorism and religious extremism.

One thought on “Is Trump A Paper Tiger Or A Sensible World Leader? – Analysis

  • June 27, 2019 at 7:54 pm

    Good analysis for the most part except the author s sure-footed assertion thiswill not degenerate into war! Trump is like Hitler i. 1938-39 rather deceptive demeanor while trash talking enemy into oblivion. Heisneithera paper tiger nor sensible please stopgiving the devil credit


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *