ISSN 2330-717X

Sri Lanka: Last Phase Of Civil War At Mullivaikal And What Really Happened – Analysis

By

By Sivanendran

The events at Mullivaikal mark the climax of the civil war in Sri Lanka, the most vicious of the battles where the lives of poor civilians were totally ignored.

That the innocent civilians got massacred in large numbers is not in doubt, but the orthodox story omits entirely the context in which this occurred.

What is most important to keep in mind is that Mullivaikal today has sadly become largely a political tool, an excuse for ethno-nationalists on all sides to let loose their most radical sentiments and score points with their supporters. In the 2009 massacre in reports, the background and responsibilities for the disaster in Mullivaikal were absent. Preferred was the simple explanation: a black and white event in which the Tamils the terrorists were solely to blame.

“Truth and reason are eternal,” Thomas Jefferson wrote to Rev. Samuel Knox in 1810. “They have prevailed. And they will eternally prevail . . .”

Mullivaikal was a village in Vanni besieged by the government forces. This massacre occurred because the Sri Lankan Army savagely lashed out s against the LTTE ignoring the civilian population of the area.. After promising safety and protection to the innocent inhabitants of Mullivaikal the governmental forces are said to have used disproportionate force indiscriminately attacking even assigned “no fire zones”.

Throughout this period the U.N. adopted a position of “neutrality” that in practice meant inaction, even when large number of men, women and children were killed in these attacks. Sri Lankan forces attacked “no fire zones” or the warring parties otherwise violated ceasefire agreements.

It’s a distasteful point, but it has to be said that, if you’re committing whole scale slaughter, you don’t let the women go since they are key to perpetuating the very group you are trying to eliminate. Many of the boys and girls were executed and buried in mass graves. Every day of this war has seen the most unspeakable atrocities committed against ordinary civilians. Trapped in this small land area, under constant Sri Lankan bombardment, sleepless and thirst-maddened, unarmed men, women and children succumbed to hallucinations, paranoia, and despair. The psyches of the people ruptured.

Mullivaikal is not simply a case of the international community standing by as a far-off atrocity was committed. The actions of the international community encouraged, aided, and emboldened the attackers. The fall of Mullivaikal did not have to happen. There was no need for thousands of skeletons to be strewn across that north eastern coast. There is no need for thousands of Tamil children to be raised on stories of their fathers, mothers, uncles and brothers slaughtered by Sri Lankan army.

How many died?

There are various estimates of the maimed and the dead. Some estimate the dead as about 10,000 whilst some others have even suggested as much as 100,000. The massacre accounts for an astonishing number of missing from the brutal conflict as a whole. By any standard, it was one of the worst and most concentrated acts of killing in the post-World War II era.

The fact beyond dispute is that during the siege of Mullivaikal thousands of Tamil men, women and children were killed. Most of them died when the enclave was completely encircled by the Sri Lankan Army and fell almost without a fight. A significant number reached safety only after the 18th May 2009.

It is now two years since the fall of Mullivaikal . Much has been written about the matter. Nonetheless the majority of reports have been limited to a broad media exposure of the event, with very little analytical rigor. Discussion of Mullivaikal cannot be limited to genocide and mass graves. A rigorous analysis of the events must take into consideration the background circumstances, in order to understand the real motives which led to the massacre.

Does Mullivaikal exemplify state brutality over the twenty five years of war? Let the truth be told. This is the question that needs to be answered by all including the international community.

Who is responsible?

The zone of Mullivaikal, like almost that entire coastline, is characterized by its flat terrain offering clear advantage to offensive forces. Sri Lankan army waited for months without attacking this enclave until the Indian elections were over. Given the resources available to both parties, and the characteristics of the terrain, it would seem that the Sri Lankan army had the necessary force to defend itself and be ever so mindful of the innocent people trapped in the war zone. This, however, did not occur.

Given the military advantage of the Sri Lankan forces it is very difficult to explain the amount of disregard that they showed to the innocent men, women and children in a siege situation, recklessly prosecuting a war in the absence of effective military resistance. The heavy casualties amongst the civilian population could have been avoided. The victims have many stories to tell. There are about 300,000 who survived these onslaughts waiting to tell their stories. There is no one asking for their stories much less to listen to them. There are many harrowing tales from these victims of Mullivaikal yet to be told.

The international community also bears responsibility for this massacre. Had the UN asserted its authority perhaps the world would have been spared of these mass killings.

The aftermath

Extensive forensic investigations of the Mullivaikal massacre sites have not been carried out systematically to identify the bodies and bury them appropriately. That area has been out of bounds to its inhabitants except the Sri Lankan military to enable them to clean up the land. We still do not know what the Sri Lankan army has done to the bodies. Is there a combined memorial or a mortuary in Mullivaikal for the dead?

The memory of Mullivaikal’s dead men women and children was kept alive by the surviving victims. They will continue to raise the memory at all international forums and will not rest until the truth is revealed.

Since the ending of the war in May 2009, the Tamil Diaspora has continued with their protest at the stalled investigations into the fate of their missing men, women and children and will do so again on the second anniversary of the massacre in May 2011. Their list of primary demands would include:

1.The full facts of massacre should be revealed and publicised.

2. A list of all dead and executed to be identified without delay.

3. A list of all survivors of Mullivaikal held prisoner in Sri Lanka should be released immediately.

So, here we are, two years later, going over the same old lines, while the families of the victims of Mullivaikal win nothing more than the moral high ground, which provides little in the way of closure. But, then, even closure is a tricky business. Even if the perpetrators themselves were to admit to the genocide and pay for their crimes, justice would not be served and the dead will not be brought back to life:

After all these years, there is still not a single high-profile political figure in Sri Lanka–who is capable of thinking of humanity over politics, of country over career. How can the people of Sri Lanka shrug it off not as the massacre of thousands of human beings, but as a tool to be used in political games?

UN Secretary General

A UN Secretary-General is not responsible for all UN actions – or lack of such, or for decisions made by the Security Council. Mr Bank ki Moon is however responsible for his own actions. During those fateful days in 2009, he had a choice: standing up against the Security Council in an attempt to shame politicians into intervening or keeping his head down and pretend he didn’t know what was going on. Mr Moon chose silence, which satisfied the governments bent on ’business as usual’: seeing nothing and hearing nothing..

It has been argued that the Security Council was not really ‘interested’ or ‘willing’ to intervene and that this exempts him from blame. It is agreed that many politicians were extremely reluctant to intervene with force in Sri Lanka. But is it not exactly during such times when we most need a Secretary-General of the United Nations to speak up? Or, put differently, if politicians were head over heels to intervene to prevent crimes against humanity, why would we need a Secretary-General of the United Nations? Besides, the (unfortunately very belated) intervention of Britain and France almost at the end of the massacre showed that it was indeed possible to create enough public awareness for the international community to react.

If Mr Ban ki Moon had vigorously demanded a UN intervention and thereby confronted those governments in the Security Council that left civilians to their killers, he could rightly have washed his hands as he has since tried to do. However, for reasons of political and bureaucratic expediency he chose not to do so.

The United Nations must shoulder a large share of responsibility for allowing the massacre to take place under their noses however odious the LTTE tactics were. Through error, misjudgement and the inability to recognize the scope of evil confronting them, they failed to do their part to save the people of Mullivaikal from the mass murder.

The blame surely extends to the member states of the United Nations.

In the final days and hours of the advance on Mullivaikal, which American and Indian intelligence could monitor closely, the international community fell strangely silent. Mullivaikal duly fell, with consequences which were unspeakable in human terms, but not inconvenient diplomatically.

Mullivaikal– A call for justice

The Sri Lankan government deny that that there is anything to be explained or debated on this matter. This was only a problem of terrorism and its elimination. So many thousands people were killed and unknown number of prisoners were executed is not a matter that needs investigation. Even if a distinguished international judicial forum of unquestioned authority has found it to constitute unacceptable does not appear to persuade the Sri Lankan government that there is a need for an appropriate investigation of the matter. According to them there is nothing to debate because everything is settled and clear.

However, for the Tamils, it is noteworthy that “Mullivaikal” is used not as a geographic location but as a stand-alone term that denotes horror, “Mullivaikal” used in this sense has established itself as a horrible massacre of the innocent Tamils. Is Mullivaikal a hoax? Is it a myth based on a lie?

A distinguished panel of reasonable people with no ethno-religious axe to grind in the Sri Lankan quagmire have called for an investigation. If Sri Lanka has no blood on its hands why not agree for such an international investigation to bring a closure to this tragedy. We repeat- Let the truth be told.

SAAG

SAAG

SAAG is the South Asia Analysis Group, a non-profit, non-commercial think tank. The objective of SAAG is to advance strategic analysis and contribute to the expansion of knowledge of Indian and International security and promote public understanding.

6 thoughts on “Sri Lanka: Last Phase Of Civil War At Mullivaikal And What Really Happened – Analysis

  • Avatar
    April 29, 2011 at 5:56 pm
    Permalink

    AN ACCESSORY AFTER THE FACT:

    UN has a responsibilty to protect. It is not an employment centre for war criminals.
    1. May 09 was not the first time UNSG Ban Ki Moon knew about the Ethnic cleansing in that country

    2. He knows very well that Internal colonialism with military governorship is still on.

    Reply
  • Avatar
    April 30, 2011 at 7:12 am
    Permalink

    Tamils have been subjected to a series of pogroms by Sinhalese mobs supported by the Sinhalese governments since independence up to the 80s. Then the ”baton” was handed over to the armed forces with unlimited impunity to wreak havoc on Tamils and to damage control at the intergovernmental fora.
    Mullivaikal is the visible culmination.
    Invisible is what has been going on since then in the Northeast: no-go area for journalists and foreigners – they need hard-to-get MoD clearance to go there.

    Reply
  • Avatar
    April 30, 2011 at 8:59 pm
    Permalink

    The innocent Tamils human tragedy in Eelam is a total failure of the International Community – Blatant failure of R2P.

    Barack Obama was in the White house who said that he will tear down rogue regimes during his election campaign but done nothing prevent human catastrophe.

    Later an Osgoode Law School (a Prestigious Canadian University for Law) Professor wrote a informative article “Taking Tea With Torturers” and it provides details of relationships that are more important than humanity and principles.

    Shameless Vijay Nambiar, an Indian Malayalee should have excluded himself to be the representative of the UN in Sri Lanka as his brother Satish Nambiar was an advisor to the Rajapakse regime as well as other Malayales MK Narayanan and Shiva Shankar Menon were in contact and collaborating on behalf of the Indian government in committing genocide and war crimes against Tamils.

    Ban Ki-moon’s actions are evidence that he has failed to prevent mass murders, rape, torture and other atrocities committed by the Sri Lankan regime forces and their gangs.

    Even after the end of the War, the International Community failed to prevent mass rape, torture and murder as Tamils were detained in detention camps, abducted at night, raped, tortured and murdered in large numbers. Now hundreds of thousands of innocents Tamils have disappeared after the war and no action taken by India, international Community and UN.

    Now almost 2 years after the end of the War, although the Rajapakse regime has celebrated the defeat of the LTTE, Tamil areas, Tamils and their representatives cannot be accessed by International Media, Journalists, NGOs, Human Rights Groups and Foreign Humanitarian organizations and the Army is in full control, occupying Tamil Lands, brutalizing and terrorizing Tamils and treat the Tamils worse than slaves.

    What does it show to the world?

    Rajapakse is in fact, he was not fighting the LTTE, he came to power with the help of the LTTE, protect and entertain KP, Karuna and other LTTE Terrorists (now puppets of the Rajapakse regime) in order for him to commit genocide, crimes against humanity and ethnic cleansing of Tamils.

    Progressive Sinhala and independent Journalists are powerless and already about 50 local Journalists were attached, arrested, intimidated and killed by this regime with impunity. Rajapske has been successful in manipulating, bullying, misleading and fooling the International Community, Western nations and others. How long the Rajapakses can continue to be successful is a million dollar question?

    Reply
  • Avatar
    May 1, 2011 at 9:26 am
    Permalink

    Let us to begin with, not miss the wood for the trees !What was the main reason for the escalation
    of the conflict? It was plainly the intransigence of the LTTE terrorists .They broke the Ceasefire agreements four times .On each occasion they lambasted the Military Forces who were caught completely unawares and on the defensive.The attacks
    were as savage as they were as cowardly ! The then Governments were taken for ride and what a ride it was,until the present GOSL took the bull by the
    horns! The rest is history. Have Sivendran & Co.
    forgotten the havoc caused by the cowardly LTTE
    to the national assets of this nation and the killing of innocent civilians including women and
    children .Mullivaikal and the carnage would never have happened in the first place ,if the so called
    most disciplined nationalistic terror organisation
    in the world,displayed a little more regard to the
    Geneva Convention! Perhaps the Armed Forces had no
    choice but to meet savagery with controlled savagery! Remember they were fighting for their lives and the Nation! What perhaps requires to be
    is to obtain first hand information from all those
    military forces who were lucky enough to come out
    alive,even though injured from the front lines in
    the last phase of the conflict. Each of them, is a
    hero . Each service person who died in the conflict is a hero and will be remembered for ever. Let us stop the self-deception and hypocrisy
    and be true to ourselves .Plainly ,Mullivaikal was
    a creation by the ruthless,un conscienceless
    behavior of the LTTE terrorists .

    Reply
  • Avatar
    May 1, 2011 at 12:19 pm
    Permalink

    In response to Dick Perera,

    LTTE was a product of the Sinhala state terrorism and hooliganism. LTTE Helped the Rajapakse regime to come to power and the LTTE Terrors are with this regime now. KP’s name is in the Interpol list of wanted criminals and he is with the Rajapakse regime now.

    The peaceful, non-violence Tamils’ struggle for equality and human rights failed as the Sinhala Apartheid successive regimes used Sinhala hooliganism and state terrorism against innocent people. Were there any LTTE and why did the Sinhala has the riots in 1958 and 1977?

    The majority Sinhala has proved the world this race is mockery, violent, barbaric, inhuman and deny eqality and human rights to minorities and Sinhala Buddhist Monks are involved in instigating violence against Tamils, arson and sex scandals.

    The denial of International Media, Journalists, NGOs, Human Rights Groups and other Humanitarian organizations to Tamils areas is another evidence of cover up crimes, committing crimes against humanity

    How can an alleged war criminal regime be let alone to commit more and more crimes?

    How can an alleged war criminal regime conducts an investigation of their own crimes?

    Reply
  • Avatar
    May 10, 2011 at 2:13 pm
    Permalink

    “Innocent” civilians is incorrect. A huge number of Tamils in the north had been helping & protecting the Tamil Tiger terrorists for nearly 3 decades. If people give shelter to criminals they are aiding & protecting those criminals, even if they have legitimate grievances, and will suffer the consequences. That standard applies in all societies where a group takes up arms against the state.
    Those Tamils in the north who opposed the Tigers had either been murdered by the Tigers or had escaped by the time Eelam War 4 got under way. The only innocent Tamils remaining in that area were the children – to young to be able to escape from the consequences of their parents’ folly in putting their trust in a group of criminals & terrorists.

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.