Time To Be Tough With China – OpEd
Even before the ink of the Goa declaration dried, Chinese made a drastic U-turn in striking down Prime Minister Modi’s reference to Pakistan as “Mothership of terror”. By glaringly, hyphenating India and Pakistan as victims of terror, China deliberately down played Indian concerns. While China’s volte-face on issues crucial to India are not new, its tacit support is emboldening Pakistan’s unrelenting pursuit of inflicting damage to India.
With cross-order terrorism and unceasing infiltration across LoC reaching newer heights, China’s reluctance to incorporate cross-border terrorism perpetrated by Pakistan in the Goa Declaration validates its complicity. Prime Minister Modi in a bid to propel India’s growth trajectory invested tremendous efforts in resurrecting ties with Pakistan and China in the last two years. But both neighbors, the thickest of friends, overpowered by antipathy towards India had responded inimically. China is now propping up Pakistan to keep India preoccupied with unrest and cross border tensions so that New Delhi’s ambitions of emerging as a potential regional counter balance to Beijing are thwarted.
Propping up Pakistan
In recent years, China is currently luxuriating in the huge bilateral trade deficit with India largely in its favor. While ensuring its economic and trade investment interests are least hurt Beijing is draining Indian energies by buttressing Pakistan. With Pakistan factor looming large Modi met President Xi Jinping along the margins of BRICS 2016 summit. China’s implacable attitude and obduracy are now denting Indian interests.
China’s rigidity in stalling India’s NSG membership despite repeated pleas for consideration at various levels and contentious vetoing of ban on Masood Azhar by the UNSC 1267 Sanctions committee have irked India. On September 30th, China extended technical hold on proposed UN sanctions on Azhar. It was the 5th time China tried to block India’s UN resolution since September 2014. China’s has also paralyzed Indian efforts to proscribe United Jehad Council chief Syed Salahuddin, the principal orchestrator of Kashmir insurgency. It shielded Pakistan from censure for freeing LeT commander Lakhvi and for averring on probing sources of finance to Hafiz Saeed, master mind of 26/11.
All these attempts unequivocally make China complicit in Pakistan’s terror strikes which left 19 soldiers recently at Uri. While nations defended India’s right to self-defense for launching surgical strikes on terror launch pads across LoC, China supported Pakistan’s position on Kashmir and raised doubts about Indian claims of strikes. It expressed concerns over India’s decision to completely seal the western border by 2018. China’s decision to block the tributary of Brahmaputra, Xiabu originating in Tibet from flowing into India citing construction of the most expensive Lalho hydroelectric power project undermining the interests of the lower riparian states has now sparked new tensions.
Modi in a bid to end the diplomatic unease, during his bilateral talks with Xi at Goa, raised several issues where combatting terrorism dominated the agenda. While Modi tweeted, that talks were fruitful, China’s quick reversal of stand on terror clearly indicated that Beijing connives Pakistan perfidy. As opposed to its much-touted peaceful rise policy, China’s egregious and ambitious accretion is tremendously changing global geopolitics. The rapid rise of China has perceptibly changed the dynamics of the region. China’s footprint is growing in the subcontinent eventually boxing India. With its deep pockets, China foreclosed India’s efforts of strengthening trade and bilateral relations with its neighbors. China’s expanding presence in India’s immediate vicinity is now truly intimidating.
Before landing in Goa for the BRICS summit, President Xi in his brief stopover at Dhaka extended $25 billion credit line which pales India’s $2 billion pledged by Modi last year. China has carefully revived Sonadia port project with Bangladesh. Apart from the Colombo port, Hambantota port of Sri Lanka, this Bangladesh’s port off the Bay of Bengal coast, suffices China’s aspirations of gaining access to India’s sphere of influence. China’s overwhelming influence in Maldives is well documented. By earning Afghanistan’s confidence through arms delivery and military aid, China is slowly roping in India’s traditional friend. Recently, China has pledged Nepal to modernize Army and disaster management enhanced security cooperation. A plausible agreement over extension of the rail line between Xigaze (Tibet) to Nepal border under Trans-Himalayan Railways connectivity reinforces penetrating influence of China in India’s backyard. With its iron brother, Pakistan, China is already escalating trouble in India. All these developments forebode India’s notion of South Asia and India Ocean as its natural sphere of influence.
Dynamic Strategic Alignments
Burgeoning hostilities between the West and Russia are forcing Moscow to enter Chinese orbit. China is also emerging as an indispensable partner of Russia for development in Arctic Region. In fact, Russia under China’s duress omitted any references to Pakistan based or cross-border terrorism or state-sponsored terror in Goa declaration. It must be remembered that China’s implicit leverage to North Korea flared up tensions in North Asia.
In the meanwhile, Philippines President Rodrigo Duterte gesture of extending hand of friendship to China downgrading military ties with US have come as shot in arm for Chinese claims in SCS. Addressing officials in Beijing, Duterte had perceptibly mellowed Philippines position on Scarborough Shoal and enthusiastically reached a consensus on jointly exploration of resources in South China Sea (SCS). Beijing suitably rewarded Duterte’s announcement of separation from US both militarily and economically on its turf by pledging $13.5 billion deals to Philippines. Earlier in 2012, Philippines pulled up China for taking control over Scarborough Shoal to International Court of Justice, Hague. Permanent Court of Arbitration (PCA) thrashing claims of China over territorial formations upheld Philippines claims. Disconcerted China refused to accept the judgement inviting the censure of the West.
Though China’s smaller ASEAN neighbors in SCS are miffed by Chinese claims, ASEAN meet failed to issue a statement on SCS as the resolution was blocked by Cambodia. Reciprocating Cambodia’s support China generously signed over 30 cooperative agreements in areas of agriculture, infrastructure, investment and economy. Besides, promising $600 million in aid towards country’s election, health and education. Swelling Chinese hegemony and its unprecedented penetration into various regions clearly reflects its veritable obsession to wield power.
China’s efforts to destabilize India
Within South Asia region, while the material indices gap between India and Pakistan are at all time high with Indian GDP now almost 10 times that of Pakistan, Chinese backing invigorates Islamabad to challenge India’s influence. As a matter of fact, a debt-ridden Pakistan gives a greater leeway to China to strategically penetrate it. India’s concerns of CPEC (China Pakistan Economic Corridor) passing through its legitimate territory are truly genuine.
While China made rapid forays into Indian territory way back in 1970’s through construction of Karakoram Highway, now under the ruse of CPEC, China is deploying troops in Gilgit-Baltistan region. China had indeed left no stone unturned to destabilize India. Evidences suggests that China dispatches arms to Indian rebels through Myanmar. China intermittently launches cyber-attacks and hacks strategically important Indian portals. It tried every trick in book to keep India off-balance to capitalize on the asymmetrical advantages. China is now contemplating on use of water as political tool. Before Communist regime China had 22 dams now it has over 85,000 dams both big and small.
Beijing known for its infrastructure building prowess is now planning to construct 14 dams along Brahmaputra. It has targeted rivers originating in Tibet and Xinjiang region- Arun, Indus, Sutlej, Irtysh, Illy Amur and Salween but flowing into India, Nepal, Kazakhstan, Russia and Myanmar. China which has already the water map of the region is now shying away from playing water politics if needed. Recent announcement of Renminbi’s inclusion in the elite global reserve currency club is now boding well for growing China’s economic clout. Aside, its rapid rise now Chinese ideology is slowly becoming inimical to India’s domestic arena. Beijing’s objections to US Ambassador Richard Verma’s visit to attend the Tawang festival at Arunachal Pradesh recently demonstrates China’s obstinacy towards false territorial claims.
Burgeoning Congeniality between Communists and Islamists
Waving of the Chinese and Pakistani flag in Kashmir Valley after the Friday prayers coinciding with President Xi’s visit to India is an alarming development. Pakistan flags have made their entry into the valley several decades back. But the appearance of Chinese flags as a solidarity is indeed a dangerous precedent.
While the new development is orchestrated by Pakistan, it testimonies growing congeniality of Jihadists and Communists. With Communists and Jihadists working hand in glove in the Valley why would China not veto India’s attempts to ban Azhar at the UN.
In February 2016, India witnessed brewing anti-national rhetoric with JNU at the helm of affairs heralding a new moment of fondness between Islamists and Communists. Now, after the Uri attacks, the indifferent response of Communist lobbies towards India’s retaliatory surgical strikes and the overdrive pushing India for talks with Pakistan reflects the obvious. Arrest of over 10 Naxalites by the ATS (Anti-Terrorism Squad) in Noida, planning attacks in Delhi couple of days back sums it all. Clearly, a coordinated network of anti-nationals is turning the nation into asunder. Till now India media has significant chunk of Pakistan sympathizers, now China baiters are making their way into main stream media unabashedly playing a pro-China card. This quick turn of events is truly alarming and demands immediate attention of various strata of Indian administration.
Clearly apart from the border disputes, India and China have several outstanding issues to sort out. An economically strong and resilient India can alone circumvent overwhelming influence of China. The panacea of all strategic aliments afflicting India lies in sturdy economic growth and development.
India in its attempts to tame the prodigal Dragon must press the right levers of Tibet and Xinjiang to its advantage. Earlier this year, India withdrew visa issued to Uighur activist Dolkun Isa for the fear of political reprisals. But now, India displayed some mettle by consenting to allow Dalai Lama visit Arunachal Pradesh scheduled for next year March. Despite India’s largesse towards China in recommending it for the UNSC permanent membership and later helping it get entry into WTO, China never reciprocated. China is now building several multilaterals institutions like Shanghai Cooperation Organization (SCO), New Development Bank and Asia Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB).
India lent its support to all these frameworks. In return, China never supported India’s bid for an extended UNSC, stalled NSG membership, vetoed Azhar’s ban, capitalized on Indo-Pakistan disputes and propped up Pakistan to expedite its anti-India agenda. China unequivocally questions India’s growing closeness with US invoking threat of regional imbalances even as it continues to extend its tentacles into India’s neighborhood. With every passing year, bilateral trade is drifting largely in favor of China reducing India to a supplier of raw materials and dump yard for low quality Chinese products.
India must evolve a policy whereby trade deficits can be reduced. With potential to grow faster and by providing free access to 1.3 billion strong markets India can’t afford to remain hamstrung. While Beijing voices concerns about Indo-Vietnam collaboration to explore oil in Vietnam’s exclusive economic zone in SCS, Delhi is expected to remain as mute spectator even as China explores India’s legitimate territory for economic gains.
Delhi should now support Pakistan lawmakers who expressed concerns over CPEC as “another East India Company in offing” and worried that CPEC is now aided by local financing instead of Chinese funding. China is capitalizing on Indian deficiencies. Delhi has a poor reputation of delaying foreign projects. India should shed the laggard image and proactively engage with neighboring countries in collaborative projects assuring timely completion of projects. Alternatively, it can competitively bid for infrastructure projects in immediate neighborhood with like-minded partners like Japan. Above all, it is time to hone diplomatic skills invoking the incisive Chanakya’s Raja Mandala theory of hard diplomacy and steer the economy by implementing tough economic reforms.
*Ramaharitha Pusarla is a freelance writer and columnist.
2 thoughts on “Time To Be Tough With China – OpEd”
A good analysis but will India ever wake up from the rip van winkle sleep?. If it does, it will realise how dangerous the situation has become.Much of what Ramaharitha has argued are obvious and have been in the making since independence. The Chinese duplicity, betrayal and its long term sinister design over India must have been obvious even to a blind person, especially when China invaded India and inflicted a humiliating defeat taking chunks of Indian territory in 1962. This was soon after premier Chou En Lai went round saying ”Hindi Chini bhai bhai”while on visit to India. However, short-sighted,corrupt, irresponsible and cowardly political leaders of all parties chose to ignore the dangers for short term personal gains at the expense of national security thereby betraying the masses in the name of ”democracy”. All political parties are complicit but Congress more than others is much more responsible. It instituted and nurtured the vote bank politics thereby reducing the nation to impotence. Nehru and Ghandhi laid the foundation for India’s impotence. Nehru was reported to have said India does not need an army as it has no enemies and and it needs only a police force. They never learnt any useful lessons and did not let in others who could do better,either. Add to that the fact they designed a flawed constitution which was exploited to develop a destructive and appeasement political culture in which there is endless arguments and no consensus on any issues, not even on threats to national security.Parliament has become a circus providing tamaasha for much of the time, all in the name of ”democracy”. As they say, what you sow is what you reap.India expecting the rest of the world to help it to solve its problems will not wash in the real world. India with 1.2 billion people (almost as much as China’s) has enormous resources, both human and natural. What it solely lacks is the much needed political will. Will India ever wake up and act?.Only time will tell.
“A good analysis but will India ever wake up from the rip van winkle sleep?. ”
People are reading the OpEd…amazing. It may take 10 years for India to wake up…it depends on what God and gods do…only then…another way is… it is a heavenly act! Indians are good at it.
Otherwise, do not mess with China….