Lessons From The Taliban: Only A Secular Democracy Can Keep India Integrated – OpEd


By Brig. Deepak Sethi (retd)*

The Taliban’s capture of power in Afghanistan has grave geostrategic ramifications. It signals Islamic resurgence, affecting not only the wide swathe of Muslim nations stretching from North Africa, the Middle East, Turkey, Central Asia, Gulf nations, South Asia, to Southeast Asia, but also countries with large Muslim populations.

Is it a moderate Taliban, or will it rigidly enforce the Sharia against women? Will it temper its radicalism to gain acceptability and get financial aid from the West, or would China bankroll it to advance its own strategic goals in Central Asia? Another serious concern is whether the Taliban would again shelter jihadi groups.  

The implications for India are more worrisome since the Taliban now has overt support of China and Russia apart from its patron Pakistan. How would this dynamic influence India’s large Muslim population, which feels alienated due to the belligerence of organizations under the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh (RSS) umbrella?

Hindu-Muslim polarization

RSS’s Hindu Rashtra fixation made it collaborate with the British instead of participating in the Gandhiji-led freedom struggle. Communal passions inflamed both by the RSS and Muslim League led to the holocaust of partition and Gandhiji’s assassination. Banned twice each by the British and independent India, it refused to accept the Indian Constitution and the tricolour.

India was never an integrated Hindu nation even during the pre-Islamic era when independent kingdoms perpetually fought amongst themselves for power, not religion. Only the British consolidated them into present-day India.

Thanks to India’s excellent Constitution and early leaders and politicians, the country remained united as a secular democracy. However, during the politically unstable 1980s, the religious frenzy generated about Ram Mandir, through then BJP president Lal Krishna Advani’s chariot campaign, and Babri Masjid demolition, Mumbai bombings, Gujarat carnage, terror attacks and 2020 Delhi riots have caused severe damage to our social fabric and economy.

It is widely believed by political analysts that Hindu-Muslim polarization helped BJP gain power at the center and several states, which could facilitate constitutional amendment for declaring India a “Hindu Rashtra” (Hindu nation). That option is fading since hate-mongering can only give diminishing returns. Moreover, people are angry over the high pandemic deaths, oxygen shortages, unemployment, poverty, farmers’ protests, and skyrocketing prices.  

Attack on secular institutions

Hindus, constituting 79.8 percent of the population, are not monolithic. BJP won 303 seats in the 2019 polls with just 37 percent of the votes. 

Hindutva has traction only in the Hindi heartland since southern India resents Hindi imposition and the northeastern states, a cultural invasion. Moderate Hindus, minorities, women, and youth hate its obscurantist, medieval, and patriarchic ideology and Taliban-style diktats on dress and morality.

Since 2014, the BJP has avowed secularism in public but passed laws tacitly targeting Muslims and failing to act against assaults on Muslims by militant Hindutva organizations. By reportedly planting Hindutva believers in constitutional positions mandated to be independent watchdogs, and by tightly controlling the narrative through a lapdog media, it has accumulated all the tools of authoritarian regimes.

Traditionally the secular armed forces have been influenced in a subtle manner, through innocuous seminars on nationalism, Vedic culture  and Hindu heritage depending on the personal orientation of the top commanders. The veterans’ grapevine indicates that this trend has been on the increase in recent years. 

Former Chief of Army Staff (COAS) General VK Singh’s public appearance soon after retirement in RSS uniform to join the BJP raised many eyebrows. The government later handpicked the first Chief of Defence Staff, Bipin Rawat, superseding his seniors. The Sangh, reportedly, now clears all senior promotions. Veterans who subscribe to Hindutva are reportedly given IT services contracts for its propaganda machine and lucrative assignments as paneled “experts” and “motivational speakers” for schools/colleges and TV shows.

But why subvert India’s most secular institution and destroy its professionalism? Is it because the army remains strictly non-partisan and professional while restoring law & order, as during the Gujarat riots?  Unlike the British Indian Army, which fired on innocents in Jallianwala Bagh, soldiers today are aware of court rulings on unlawful commands, “ketchup colonels” and trigger-happy personnel.

Moderate voices need assertion

Religious, sectarian, and ethnic conflicts inevitably lead to mass deaths and mayhem. Will not the region head towards a clash between a resurgent Islam and militant Hindutva with dreadful consequences?

Sane and moderate people in all communities vastly outnumber the radical fringe whose bigotry and xenophobia invariably destroy societies. They must assert themselves to restrain such elements in their respective communities from hostile actions and jingoism that could set the nation aflame.

In the absence of any one of Gandhiji’s moral authority, our Constitution should remain our beacon. Secular democracy enshrined in it as a basic principle alone can keep the nation integrated, where all people irrespective of religious, social, cultural, ethnic, and economic backgrounds enjoy the same freedoms and equality.

Sanity in public discourse  and socio-religous harmony are  imperative for India in the current disturbed regional and internal environment.

*About the author: The writer, an Indian Army veteran, is Professor of International Business Strategy and Management, Charlotte, North Carolina, USA. The views expressed are personal and not necessarily shared by editors of South Asia Monitor. He can be contacted at [email protected]

Source: This article was published by South Asia Monitor

South Asia Monitor

To create a more credible and empathetic knowledge bank on the South Asian region, SPS curates the South Asia Monitor (www.southasiamonitor.org), an independent web journal and online resource dealing with strategic, political, security, cultural and economic issues about, pertaining to and of consequence to South Asia and the Indo-Pacific region. Developed for South Asia watchers across the globe or those looking for in-depth knowledge, reliable resource and documentation on this region, the site features exclusive commentaries, insightful analyses, interviews and reviews contributed by strategic experts, diplomats, journalists, analysts, researchers and students from not only this region but all over the world. It also aggregates news, views commentary content related to the region and the extended neighbourhood.

2 thoughts on “Lessons From The Taliban: Only A Secular Democracy Can Keep India Integrated – OpEd

  • September 3, 2021 at 1:32 pm

    It is only Hindutva that will defend India. people like Deepak Sethi will take a flight at first defeat against Talibani type people. Secularist part of Indian army will melt away against Talibanis like Afghan army melt away. So Indian people will be better off relying on Hindutva to protect them rather than depend upon secularists to defend them.

    It is shocking that Indian army had so many sycophants like Sethi, Ram das etc.

  • September 4, 2021 at 2:41 pm

    Where was hindutva when the Ghaznavids and Ghurids invaded Rajasthan? Or when the EIC defeated the Marathas and established their rule in the Gangetic Doab? It is foolish to assume that what failed so many times before will succeed now.

    India needs science and effective bureaucracy to defend itself,not shivlings


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *