ISSN 2330-717X

Malaysia: Desperately Needing A New National Narrative – Analysis

The ritualistic month long celebration of Merdeka (independence) activities have largely lost their meaning. Discussion about the roles that different groups played in the road to independence has largely been rewritten to support the current rulers of today. The celebration of 31st August, the day Malaya gained independence from the British as the major national day seems to exclude the aspirations of Sabahans and Sarawakians, where on 16th September 1963 they joined Malaya and Singapore in a union called Malaysia. Groups like the Communist Party of Malaya which fought and lost many lives against both the British and Japanese are almost totally excluded from the nation’s Merdeka narrative.

This is all occurring in an environment desperately in need of a narrative of inclusiveness.

The current Merdeka celebration suppresses the generation of new ideas and a national creativity that could spring up from an environment of inclusiveness. The Merdeka celebrations have severed any empathetic connections between Malaysia’s the various elements within the rich and diverse history of the country, replacing it with a single narrative one would find on a cellulose film like “Tanda Putera”. A whole generation of people now exist who behave according to the beliefs and values incorporated within this narrow narrative.
This denies the cascade of alternative realities and their accompanying narratives which stifles national creativity and evolution that Malaysia needs to face the challenges before it.

The Merdeka celebrations fail to incorporate any evolving aspirations that would promote and enhance the semblance of national unity.

Ironically under the Mahathir years, a strong national narrative existed which at the time appeared to be shared by middle class Malaysian society. Malaysia in the 80s and early 90s had a deep sense of national pride where any senses of inferiority were thrown out of the window with the catch cry of “Malaysia Boleh”. Many people at the time believed that Malaysia was the best country to live in. Almost 25 years on these feelings have been replaced with a sense of disappear over law and order, corruption, religious intolerance, and self indulgence.

The fact that Malaysia has many domestic issues to solve and it’s place in the world is slipping away, according to many international rankings, is largely out of the national discussion and public agenda. Rather it appears division is in everybody’s best interests, from school administrations right up to the highest echelons of government.

Malaysia has lost that true spiritual unity between people that was the catalyst that brought independence to the nation in the first place, first with the British during the 1950s and then between the parties that made up the Malaysian union in 1963.

What is missing today are aspirations about the purpose and ‘dreams’ the country was founded upon during the struggle for independence, and subsequent search for its identity as a nation. Malaysia as a nation is yet to realize that diversity has a spiritual unity about it. Suppress it and the national narrative becomes one without optimism for a ‘just and equitable society’.

The current national narrative is one captive under the old traditional caste system with little relevance to the needs of contemporary society. Consequently the Malaysian mind is a prisoner of this paradigm, unlikely to break free to enable an enlightened society.

The Malaysian rulers have felt insecure with their own values, preferring to adopt a neo-colonial development paradigm of unquestioned growth, and development and profiteering. Development has been a game for the elite, without any questioning of this occidental paradigm.

Greed and intolerance have developed into two of the most important post Merdeka qualities. This has been at a great cost to the development of any sense of shared spiritualism about the country. Malaysia is in need of the qualities of compassion, tolerance, mercy and forgiveness as the assumptions behind any national development agenda. This is where the universal values of Islam are important and where the true sense of an Islamic state really exists. Islam must be viewed as a way to enhance the quality of society rather than a tool to control society.

The banning of books, the demolition of buildings, and the suppression of many practices is causing the cream of Malaysia’s society to flee. Repression through brute force has cost the country dearly. Crony capitalism and corruption is keeping Malaysia in the relative ‘dark ages’. A relative static view of the economic pie lowers any national sense of vision. This parochial thinking is preventing any vision of a progressive and prosperous Malaysia in the coming decades, which may actually force Malaysia to become a slave to the new emerging world order.

Malaysia must find its own dream rather than adopting those of other nations. The aspirations of multi-media super corridors, Cyberjaya, and biotechnology clusters, are the stuff of other peoples’ dreams, preventing the creation of something that could be uniquely Malaysian.

Many groups are dispossessed and have no part in the national narrative. Rather capitalistic greed entrenched within ‘so-called’ development projects in the name of national development and unity continue to by-pass the poor and needy. Malaysia is not only divided by race, but by socio-economic class, taking the country further away from any notion of a single ‘Bangsa Malaysia”.

History has been written by those who have dominated society. Malaysians have been blinded by the political paradigm created by those who rule, preventing people from seeing new possibilities. This history doesn’t match Malaysia’s contemporary aspirations.

The evils of this progress will be felt by future generations of Malaysians who will have to pay dearly when picking up the pieces of a destitute and stripped environment that others before them have ravaged.
As UMNO, the ruling party goes back into the shell of ‘Ketuanan Melayu’ (Malay superiority), the language of intolerance and inequality will continue and maintain a divided Malaysia. This ignores the needs of a rapidly changing society, which will almost certainly bring further friction where the illusion of harmony may come to an abrupt end.

The current divisions within UMNO are serving the interests of a select few who can dictate the agenda. This will prevent UMNO learning how to reengage its traditional constituency again and reform itself in the spirit of Merdeka once again.

However at the same time, the popular vote of the last election strongly indicates that the majority of people are looking for some form of genuine change within Malaysian society. But, the election was really just a hope or even fantasy, that any outcome would actually bring change of any significant nature. Real change could not occur, as all the parties involved within the political process are institutionalized. Any real change requires a complete rebirth of ideas and new processes to accompany them. This requires a totally frank national dialogue in the spirit of accepting diversity in the spirit of those people who worked together to achieve Merdeka more than 50 years ago.

One may have to question the results of the Malaysian political system as being an occidental outcome, where a Malaysian solution is required. The Westminster system supports an adversarial system of government and opposition. Maybe the Malaysian political process should be much more consultative, like it once was. National unity coalitions may serve Malaysia better than the current adversarial system of government and opposition. It’s time to explore these possibilities for the sake of Malaysia’s future.

Policy must be looked at through apolitical eyes, consensus and bi-partisanship. This is more the Malaysian way, where this new sense of national unity will also help develop this elusive or even mythical ‘Malay unity’ that many are seeking. Malaysia is not yet a large enough country where it can afford to divide it’s administrative talent between government and opposition. All hands are needed on the deck of government for Malaysia to prosper.

The underlying message of GE-13 in terms of both the popular vote and seat results could be interpreted as a general wish for all to work together regardless of race, colour, or creed.

This is where the new Malaysia could be born, where justice and equity could be achieved. Malaysians must move onto new truths and reconciliations in the belief of one nation Malaysia. Otherwise Malaysia will continue to be divided with increasing frictions.

This new rebirth requires a scrapping of the current race based political system, something often talked about. Race based idealism must be replaced with policy based idealism, where governments work upon a platform based on consensus. Ritual must be replaced with principled pragmatism with ample social discussion on how Malaysia should be shaped for the future.


About the Author

Murray Hunter
Murray Hunter
Murray Hunter has been involved in Asia-Pacific business for the last 30 years as an entrepreneur, consultant, academic, and researcher. As an entrepreneur he was involved in numerous start-ups, developing a lot of patented technology, where one of his enterprises was listed in 1992 as the 5th fastest going company on the BRW/Price Waterhouse Fast100 list in Australia. Murray is now an associate professor at the University Malaysia Perlis, spending a lot of time consulting to Asian governments on community development and village biotechnology, both at the strategic level and “on the ground”. He is also a visiting professor at a number of universities and regular speaker at conferences and workshops in the region. Murray is the author of a number of books, numerous research and conceptual papers in referred journals, and commentator on the issues of entrepreneurship, development, and politics in a number of magazines and online news sites around the world. Murray takes a trans-disciplinary view of issues and events, trying to relate this to the enrichment and empowerment of people in the region.

Be the first to comment on "Malaysia: Desperately Needing A New National Narrative – Analysis"

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.


*


CLOSE
CLOSE