ISKP Rejects Taliban’s Fatwa: A Dispute Over Religious Authority – OpEd


The Islamic State Khorasan Province (ISKP) recently released a 59-page booklet in Pashto that has sent shockwaves through the region. In this document, the ISKP nullified the Fatwa issued by the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan (IEA) and even went a step further by inviting low-ranking Taliban members to join its ranks. This move signifies a complex and troubling development, shedding light on a dispute over religious authority, alliances, and the ongoing power struggle within Afghanistan’s turbulent landscape.

The ISKP’s rejection of the IEA’s Fatwa has significant implications. The Fatwa, issued by the IEA, was rooted in Sharia law, serving as a religious decree aimed at consolidating the authority of the Taliban over Afghanistan. The fact that the ISKP chose to dismiss this Fatwa reflects a direct challenge to the IEA’s religious and political legitimacy.

This dispute over religious authority within Afghanistan’s Islamist landscape is indicative of the deep-rooted ideological divisions that continue to plague the region. It highlights the ISKP’s determination to chart its own course, outside the realm of the Taliban’s authority, and underscores the complexities of interpreting Islamic law in a way that aligns with specific political agendas.

A Nexus of Terror: ISKP-TTP Against TTA

The ISKP’s rejection of the IEA’s Fatwa is not an isolated incident. There is an ongoing nexus between the ISKP and the Tehrik-i-Taliban Pakistan (TTP) aimed at countering the influence and control of the Taliban in Afghanistan (TTA). The TTP has already given a twisted explanation of the decree by the Taliban, hinting at a potential alignment with the ISKP’s stance to reject the Fatwa.

This alignment between the ISKP and the TTP against the TTA demonstrates the complex web of allegiances and rivalries that define the region’s militant landscape. It also underscores the challenges the IEA faces in consolidating its rule and imposing its religious decrees across Afghanistan.

The ISKP’s strategic choice to encourage defections among lower-ranking IEA officials is not unique. It aligns with broader terrorist tactics, where extremist factions seek to weaken their enemies from within by fostering internal conflicts. By targeting low-ranking Taliban members, the ISKP aims to create dissension and disarray within the ranks of its rival group, further destabilizing the already fragile situation in Afghanistan.

The invitation extended by the ISKP to low-ranking Taliban members to join its ranks is a troubling development. It reveals the ISKP’s willingness to exploit disillusionment and dissent within the Taliban’s ranks, potentially sowing the seeds of further conflict and division. This move should serve as a stark reminder of the ever-present threat posed by extremist groups that seek to exploit vulnerabilities within Afghanistan.

It’s essential to note that allegations have been made suggesting that the ISKP operates as an Indian proxy and pursues an anti-Muslim and anti-Islam agenda. While such claims should be critically examined and based on credible evidence, they underscore the complexities of regional dynamics and the role of external actors in Afghanistan’s security landscape.


The ISKP’s rejection of the IEA’s Fatwa, along with its invitation to low-ranking Taliban members, is a concerning development that reflects a dispute over religious authority and a deepening power struggle within Afghanistan. This move highlights the ISKP’s determination to carve out its own path and challenge the religious and political legitimacy of the Taliban. The ongoing nexus between the ISKP and the TTP against the TTA further complicates the situation in Afghanistan, making it imperative for the IEA to assert control and stability over the nation. Fostering internal conflict and extending invitations to defectors are tactics often employed by extremist groups, underscoring the need for vigilance and unity in the face of such threats. As Afghanistan continues to grapple with these challenges, it remains essential for the international community to closely monitor developments in the region and work towards a peaceful and stable Afghanistan that can resist the influence of extremist factions like the ISKP. 

Khalid Iqbal

Khalid Iqbal is a BS student at NUML, Islamabad.

One thought on “ISKP Rejects Taliban’s Fatwa: A Dispute Over Religious Authority – OpEd

  • September 9, 2023 at 7:48 pm

    Is this “just” a power rivalry or other, that is, ideological/doctrinal?

    And could someone point non-Muslim readers to the main ideological/doctrinal differences and to the scriptures on which they are based?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *