G-20 Summit: Diplomatic Triumph For India To Blunt China And Outshine ASEAN – OpEd


Notwithstanding political rifts, Congress leader Sashi Tharoor lauded the New Delhi declaration of G -20 a diplomatic triumph for India. It pushed India to the leadership for Global South, leveraging its political clout in the world. Eventually, induction of 55 members of AU (African Union) as permanent members. The G-20 accredited Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s  assertion for a new era of G-20. It unleashed a striking success in geopolitics and catapulted  India a major counterweight to China , vis-à-vis, proxy for USA. 

Simultaneously, India’s spurring growth in the economy up the ante to blunt China . China, which was the biggest workshop for supply chain, is losing steam. This will have a consequential impact on ASEAN growth, which is portrayed as the alternative to China for supply chain. China – ASEAN economies are intertwined. If China grows, ASEAN economy gear up and vice-versa. 

China’s economic growth has been dragged into progressive deceleration. Its GDP growth fell to 3 percent in 2022 and is projected to fall further in 2023. It has entered deflation, raising a paranoia for recession, akin to Japan. 

 Concern on  Chinese slow growth reverberated in ASEAN. China has been the biggest trading partner of ASEAN.  Lackluster  domestic demand led  ASEAN to depend on trade for growth. Till 2021, China was both biggest export destination and import source for ASEAN. But in 2022 China was toppled by USA for he biggest export destination for ASEAN.

Theses translate that slow growth in China had a cascading impact on ASEAN. In 2022, ASEAN exports to China increased merely by 2.9 percent, against 28.7 percent in 2021. These led USA to overtake China in exports. Exports to USA increased by 13.7percent. 

Global institutes like IMF and OECD are uncertain for sustainable growth in ASEAN. They predicted an erratic growth  for ASEAN, given the slow growth of China 

This translates a diversification from China to USA has become significant for ASEAN growth. Had this diversification not been made, ASEAN growth would have been vulnerable, owing to China’s falling.   

In addition, the contentious  issue between China and ASEAN, like South China sea , particularly with Vietnam  , continues a   paradox for mitigating the political wranglings. 

In the meantime , India emerged 5th largest economy. The growth trajectory paves the way for    India to be the 3rd largest economy by the end of this decade.  It is the   biggest pool of working population, after China sinks in aging. Rural consumption emerged the backbone for growth.

To increase its political ascendancy and economic influences  in South East Asia, mainly in ASEAN, China was asserting for RCEP,   where  USA and India are not members.  It is colloquially known as China led trade.  block . In other words, China’s fall translates uncertainty for RCEP. It includes ASEAN 10 plus China , Australia, New Zealand, South Korea , Japan.  

 Besides , China   has been using soft loan mechanism for development of infrastructure in the ASEAN  through BRI ( Belt and Road Initiative), which   act  a greater political and economic influence in the region. But , BRI is losing steam due to rising debt burden of the members. Sri Lanka lost its Hambantota Port and Italy withdrew from the project. 

New Delhi declaration in G-20 summit for IMEC ( India- Middle east – European Corridor)  will pose   a  major challenge to Chinese BRI ( Belt and Road Infrastructure) . IMEC  will transport goods from India to Europe through UAE, Saudi Arab, Jordon and Israel. It is shorter than the Suez canal route. 

According to IMF,  the growth projections of 4 majors of ASEAN are lower than India in 2023 and 2024.  While India’s growth are projected at 5.2 percent and 6.3 percent in 2023 and 2024 respectively,  growth projections for   ASEAN majors Singapore, Thailand, Malaysia and Indonesia are  at lower pace. Only Vietnam vies challenge to India’s growth.   

Given these and  ASEAN growth dependency on  two  political rivals , viz, USA and China,  ASEAN growth looms on vulnrability. This warrants a caution for dependency on ASEAN for alternative supply chain to China. 

In contrast , India has emerged a new era of  manufacturing potential by various policy measures in recent years. Thanks to PLI( Productivity Linked Incentive)  scheme, which bolstered India’s manufacturing competition.   Phrase “ factory Asia” for ASEAN is losing its fanfare , with India emerging a major bet for the investors. 

Given  the launch of PLI scheme three years ago, investment soared in the new industries in India. According to NITI Aayoog,  up to June 2023 since PLI was launched in 2020, fresh investment in medical devices increased by about 80 percent of the expected investment and  60 percent  in  large scale electronics manufacturing , including mobile phones, of  the expected investment.   . 

These  enhanced both output and exports of these sectors. During 2014-15 to 2022-23, value of electronic goods output increased from US$ 31 billion to US $ 103 billion , up by 300 percent and  exports increased from US$ 6 billion to US$ 23 billion, up nearly by 400 percent. The noteworthy growth was in manufacturing mobile phones. Production of mobile phones increased from US $ 3 billion to US$ 44 billion , up by nearly 1,700 percent. India has  become  the second biggest manufacturer of mobile phones in the world. Exports increased by 6,000 percent , from US$ 0.26 billion to US$ 11 billion.  

Eventually , India’s imports of  electronics goods  declined from China. According to GTM ( Global Trade Research Initiative) , import of electronics items from China declined from US$ 30.3 billion in 2021-b 

In summing up, India is inching towards manufacturing powerhouse by virtue of its new policy measures and global political outreach, coupled with fast growth in digitization and IT services. To this end, outshining ASEAN or  blunting Chinese hegemony in ‘factory world” are not imponderable. 

Subrata Majumder

Subrata Majumder is a former adviser to Japan External Trade Organization (JETRO), New Delhi, and the author of “Exporting to Japan,” as well as various articles in Indian media, including Business Line, Echo of India, Indian Press Agency, and foreign media, such as Asia Times online and Eurasia Review .

One thought on “G-20 Summit: Diplomatic Triumph For India To Blunt China And Outshine ASEAN – OpEd

  • September 26, 2023 at 5:09 am

    India should seize the momentum and increase its diplomatic foot prints in areas vital to its national interests . Its bureaucracy needs to be revamped to bring in the talented, committed and disciplined staffers ( of whom there is no dearth in the country) and at the same time weed out the incompetent and long-stayers who were not selected on merit. This should not be difficult. In ancient times India’s diplomacy had no rival e . g. Chanakya


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *