When Religion Becomes A Weapon, Mobs Replace Justice – OpEd
Religion is meant to guide human beings toward justice, compassion, and order. Yet across the globe today, it is increasingly weaponized by mobs who claim to defend faith but in reality desecrate it. Few countries illustrate this dangerous distortion more starkly than Pakistan.
In Islam, the duty of Amr bil Ma‘ruf wa Nahi an al-Munkar — enjoining good and forbidding evil — is foundational. The Qur’an (Aal-e-Imran 3:110) elevates Muslims as “the best community” precisely because of this responsibility. But in Pakistan, this teaching has too often been twisted into a pretext for vigilantism. The Prophet Muhammad ﷺ strictly forbade chaos and mob violence, entrusting justice to appointed authorities. Yet his words are invoked by crowds that beat, burn, and kill.
In December 2021, a Sri Lankan factory manager, Priyantha Kumara, was lynched in Sialkot on false accusations of blasphemy. Last year, in Nankana Sahib, hundreds stormed a police station, dragged out an accused man, and murdered him. In Sargodha, another mob tortured a man to death in broad daylight. These are not aberrations; they are the consequence of faith weaponized into fury.
But Pakistan is not alone. In India, Hindu nationalist mobs attack Muslims under the banner of cow protection. In Myanmar, Buddhist militias have terrorized the Rohingya. In parts of Africa, Christian and Muslim vigilantes alike invoke scripture to justify bloodshed. The pattern is global: when mobs claim the mantle of religion, justice collapses into violence, and the sacred is reduced to a slogan.
What makes the Pakistani case particularly revealing is how starkly it contradicts the Prophet’s vision. The Qur’an (An-Nisa 4:59) instructs: “Obey Allah, obey the Messenger, and those in authority among you.” Authority here means lawful institutions — judges, governors, courts — not the rage of crowds. The Prophet ﷺ never permitted mob justice. He appointed leaders and established courts so that justice could be fair, not frenzied.
Pakistan has recognized this danger. The Paigham-e-Pakistan fatwa, signed by scholars across the spectrum, declares mob vigilantism un-Islamic and unconstitutional. But enforcement remains weak, and every lynching chips away at the credibility of both religion and state. What should be a collective moral responsibility has been hijacked into personal revenge, turning faith into fire.
The Prophet’s famous saying — “Whoever among you sees an evil, let him change it with his hand; if he cannot, then with his tongue; if he cannot, then with his heart” (Sahih Muslim) — is often misused as justification for mob violence. In reality, it calls for moral courage: persuasion, prayer, and personal integrity. It is about restraint, not rage.
The tragedy of mob vigilantism in Pakistan is therefore more than national; it is emblematic of a global crisis. Around the world, when religion is transformed into a weapon, it ceases to be a source of order and becomes an excuse for chaos. The victims are not only the innocent lives lost, but also the moral authority of faith itself.
The lesson Pakistan offers the world is urgent: religion must be reclaimed from the mob. Faith flourishes through law, order, and compassion — never through lynching. If Pakistan, with its constitutional framework, judicial system, and vast network of scholars, cannot rein in vigilante violence, it risks leaving religion hostage to rage.
In the end, a society that allows mobs to define virtue surrenders both justice and faith. And that is not just Pakistan’s struggle — it is a warning to the world.
Like what you read?
Please consider supporting Eurasia Review. Thank you for your consideration!
