Balochistan Needs Equal Representation And Grievances Resolution – OpEd


Balochistan, the largest province of Pakistan, has long been at the center of a complex web of geopolitical, economic, and social challenges. The province is not only rich in natural resources but also plagued by longstanding grievances, including concerns over political representation and economic disparities. It is high time for a comprehensive approach that addresses the legitimate concerns of the Baloch people, ensuring equal representation and effective grievance resolution.

Grievances in Balochistan stem from a historical context of perceived marginalization and neglect. A deep-rooted sense of deprivation has fueled unrest and separatist movements, creating a volatile environment that hampers development initiatives. Understanding and redressing these grievances is fundamental to fostering a sense of belonging and trust among the diverse communities inhabiting the province.

One of the primary sources of discontent in Balochistan is the perception of political marginalization. Balochistan, Pakistan’s largest province by area, has long grappled with issues of political representation, leading to a sense of marginalization among its people. Addressing this concern is crucial not only for the province but also for the overall democratic fabric of Pakistan. Balochistan’s representation in the federal parliament, compared to other provinces, has been a contentious issue, and it requires careful consideration and reform to ensure the equitable participation of all provinces in the national decision-making process.

The existing imbalance in parliamentary representation stems from a historical legacy that has left Balochistan underrepresented in comparison to its population size and geographical significance. The consequences of this underrepresentation are profound, affecting the province’s ability to articulate its concerns, advocate for its interests, and partake in shaping national policies effectively. One key factor contributing to this imbalance is the disparity in population size among provinces. While the population of Punjab, the most populous province, has led to a significant representation in the federal parliament, Balochistan’s sparse population has resulted in a proportionally smaller representation. This numerical discrepancy has consequences beyond mere parliamentary seats; it influences the allocation of resources, development projects, and the overall attention given to the province’s unique challenges.

To address this issue, a fair and inclusive approach is needed to ensure that Balochistan’s representation aligns with its demographic and geographic significance. One potential solution lies in revisiting the existing electoral system and considering a proportional representation model that takes into account the diverse demographics of each province. Such a model could ensure a more accurate reflection of the population’s will, allowing for a balanced representation that is crucial for the stability and inclusivity of the federal system.

International examples, such as the Canadian model, where provinces have a significant say in national decision-making through the Senate, provide insights into how a balanced and fair representation system can be achieved. While the specifics may differ, the principles of addressing regional imbalances, ensuring equal participation, and upholding the principles of federalism remain relevant.

However, achieving equal representation and resolving grievances goes beyond mere political and economic measures. It requires a commitment to open dialogue and conflict resolution. The government must engage with the Baloch people and address their concerns through peaceful means. Initiating a comprehensive dialogue process involving all stakeholders, including tribal leaders, civil society, and political representatives, is essential for fostering trust and understanding.

It is essential to recognize that achieving equal representation for Balochistan in the federal parliament is not about privileging one province over another but about fostering a truly representative and participatory democracy. The aim is to strengthen the bonds between the provinces and the federal government, ensuring that each province has a stake in the national decision-making process.

The grievances in Balochistan are the perceived economic exploitation of its abundant natural resources. It is largely perceived that the province is rich in minerals, including natural gas, coal, and copper, yet the benefits of these resources have not adequately trickled down to the local population. Balochistan’s people rightly demand a fair share of the economic shares generated from the exploitation of their land’s wealth.

To address this issue, it is crucial to implement policies that ensure transparency and equitable distribution of resource revenues. Establishing mechanisms for revenue sharing and involving local communities in decision-making processes related to resource extraction can contribute to a more inclusive and just economic framework. Additionally, investing in infrastructure and human capital development in the province can stimulate economic activities and create employment opportunities, thereby addressing the socio-economic grievances of the people of Balochistan.

One critical constitutional issue is the distribution of resources and the provincial share in the national revenue. Balochistan’s leaders have consistently argued that the province has not received a fair share of the resources generated within its borders. Actually, Balochistan’s share of national tax revenue is about 2-3%, due to its smaller economy and limited industrial base. Balochistan’s political struggle has often taken the form of insurgency, with various armed groups seeking greater autonomy or absolute independence. The government’s response to these movements has been marked by a combination of military operations, negotiations, and attempts at political reconciliation. However, a lasting resolution remains elusive, as deep-seated grievances persist, and the constitutional framework has yet to provide a satisfactory platform for addressing the core issues.

In recent years, there have been efforts to address Balochistan’s concerns within the constitutional framework. The 18th Amendment to the Constitution in 2010, for instance, aimed to devolve greater powers to the provinces and enhance their autonomy. While this was a positive step, the practical implementation and impact on Balochistan’s political rights have been subject to debate. The formation of the National Finance Commission (NFC) award, which determines the distribution of financial resources among provinces, has also been a contentious issue.

Despite these constitutional developments, achieving a comprehensive and sustainable resolution to Balochistan’s struggle requires a multi-faceted approach. First and foremost, there must be a genuine commitment from all stakeholders to engage in open and constructive dialogue. The historical distrust between Baloch people and the central government needs to be addressed through transparent negotiations that address the root causes of the conflict.

Moreover, addressing the longstanding issue of enforced disappearances and human rights violations is paramount in addressing grievances in Balochistan. The allegations of security forces’ involvement in these actions have fueled mistrust and animosity. A transparent and accountable approach to addressing these human rights concerns is essential to rebuilding trust between the state and the people of Balochistan.

Strengthening governance structures goes hand in hand with addressing grievances. Balochistan’s unique demographic and ethnic composition necessitates a governance framework that accommodates diversity and ensures representation for all. Instituting affirmative action policies to include marginalized groups in decision-making bodies can foster a more inclusive political environment.

Infrastructure development is a linchpin for both addressing grievances and strengthening governance structures. Balochistan’s vast and challenging terrain requires strategic investments in roads, communication networks, and other basic amenities. Improved connectivity not only facilitates economic activities but also ensures that marginalized areas have access to essential services. Research indicates that infrastructure development is closely linked to poverty reduction and improved living standards. Therefore, prioritizing infrastructure projects in Balochistan can have a transformative impact on the lives of its residents, addressing some of the core grievances related to underdevelopment and neglect.

To addressing grievances, giving equal representation, equal resources distribution and strengthening governance structures are interlinked imperatives for achieving lasting stability in Balochistan. The multifaceted challenges faced by the province demand comprehensive and coordinated efforts from the government, political parties and civil society. By acknowledging historical grievances, implementing inclusive policies, and investing in the socio-economic development of the province, Balochistan can pave the way for a brighter and more stable future. The path ahead may be challenging, but the resilience and aspirations of the people of Balochistan demand nothing less than a concerted and sustained commitment to positive change. A united and representative Pakistan can only emerge when all provinces, including Balochistan, have an equal and meaningful voice in shaping the nation’s future.

Dr. Siraj Bashir

Dr. Siraj Bashir (Ph.D.), Director Research/Editor BTTN Journal, Balochistan Think Tank Network (BTTN)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *