ISSN 2330-717X

Space Weaponization: A Threat To Arms Race Stability In South Asia – OpEd

By

The space weaponization debate is getting a foothold in the international security environment. The aim to achieve global power status has urged the influential states to work on outer space. The militarization and weaponization of outer space have been in discussion for some time. The outer space weaponization is horrendous in the eyes of arms control provocateurs. India, in its aspiration, to pursue power, global status and regional hegemony didn’t lack behind in the quest and has thus followed the suit. The Indian pursuit of space weaponization is detrimental to the deterrence stability in the region, which entails two nuclear power states. Thus, the space weaponization in South Asia needs all ears before the region gets further destabilized.

In the existing global power paradigm, it has become the prerequisite to achieve success in outer space, to have a more dominant role in the decision-making process at the global level. Sustaining a modernized and up-to-date army and weaponry has always been the indispensable element of state power. The advanced weaponization of the military is believed to be an essential tangible factor in the foreign policy-making of a state and the pursuance of its national interest. India, in order to attain global status and in its pursuit to attain escalation dominance on Pakistan, is actively mobilizing its space-based activities. The Indian officials and scholars are insisting upon their government to utilize space for deterrence purposes as well. Thus, the offensive space-based capability increases the chances of any misadventure and could pursue the Indian officials to take hawkish steps against Pakistan, once they’ll have contentment over its deterrence capability, which leads to instability in the region.

The developments in the international arena, entailing the US’ withdrawal from the Open Skies Treaty, creation of its space force, and increased testing and development of the ASAT program by the major powers, has unwrapped ways for space weaponization. India considerably is pursuing its outer space program, which particularly is antagonistic towards Pakistan. Indian intentions appeared to be hazy when US President Ronald Reagan presented his Star Wars Program, and India showed ambiguity of its space program to be civilian and purely pacifist or otherwise. In March 2019, when India conducted its ASAT weapon test, it appeared to be a surprise to the international community, and considered that to be a peaceful space program, but not to Pakistan who reiterated many times about India’s intention of space weaponization.

Furthermore, the missiles don’t just cross or target the space-based assets, but could also be stationed in space, and the stationed space-based assets could also target each other in space. The militarization of space has increased the data conveyance and information availability to the states in no time, and states could gain real-time information about their adversary as well. This kind of information could be used to target the military assets of the adversary in pre-emptive attack, excessively. This would amplify uncertainty between the states and a security dilemma would be created at the adversary’s end, especially those lacking in space technology.

India has also signed an agreement with the US, which is the latest of the agreements between the two states for enhancing military cooperation. BECA (Basic Exchange and Cooperation Agreement) would allow India to get its hands on satellite data, sensitive information, and real-time access to the US geospatial intelligence. This cooperation by a superpower would tremendously increase India’s space-based capabilities and give India an edge over Pakistan in case of conflict scenario. It would also provoke India to go for a pre-emptive strike against Pakistan.

Pakistan, on the other hand, has a nascent space-based program; nevertheless, it has a space vision by 2047. Even though Pakistan is not in a contest with India over the outer space program, but the security concerns of Pakistan have always been India centric, which necessitates the espousal of concrete steps to be taken in the future for enhancing the security of the country in the context of outer space too, for maintaining the minimum credible deterrence against India. Satellites, in the technical domain, have a principal role to play and are considered as the most significant tool in case of conventional conflicts. The ASAT, on the other hand, also relentlessly affects the adversary’s capability of a second strike attack, in case it would be engaged against its C4I2SR satellite (Command, Control, Communication, Computer, Information, Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance Satellite). The sound Outer Space Program has become essential for Pakistan, for maintaining deterrence, which includes the development of remote sensing satellites, communication, and early warning satellites, and uninterrupted communication. Both the South Asian states, with bilateral mistrust and war-prone history, have found themselves in yet another competition, and a new zone of conflict has been opened by India, which could be detrimental to peace and security in the region.

*Amber Afreen Abid, Research Associate, Strategic Vision Institute, Islamabad.

2 thoughts on “Space Weaponization: A Threat To Arms Race Stability In South Asia – OpEd

  • Avatar
    April 29, 2021 at 10:32 pm
    Permalink

    You are absolutely correct to be concerned about India’s move to weaponizing of outer space. I have spent decades fighting for a treaty that bans weapons in space. In that time I worked with the United Nations, India and Pakistan, China, and many other countries to support a legal ban. Nevertheless, the issue of weapons in space is following the same path as nuclear weapons, ASATs, and other massively destructive weapons. The Conference on Disarmament, the negotiating forum for multinational treaties has been unable to move past declarations to action. In my prior contacts with India I had hoped that it would hold the high ground on potential proliferation of weapons in space. Sadly, that is not the case.
    I call on the people of the world to protest the power drive to move the arms race into space, above their heads. we need global action to stop this as it moves further and further toward reality.

    Reply
  • Avatar
    May 5, 2021 at 11:36 am
    Permalink

    India has never made any efforts to weaponize space and it never will. India’s space programmes are for the prosperity and the greater good of the mankind and was justified by the current and future Space programmes. On the other hand Pakistan military is utilizing the technology of SUPARCO – pakistan’s space agency; for ballistic missile development that ranges from 1989 Haft-I ballistic missile to recent nuclear capable Shaheen III ballistic missiles. Also for decades SUPARCO is administered by Pakistan army officers; what a military officer has to do in a space agency other than utilization of space technology that is acquired via corporation with other space agencies and eventual weaponization of space?!

    Reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.