By Nagapushpa Devendra*
The coronavirus disease (COVID-19) that emerged from Wuhan in China in December 2019 has engulfed almost every country in the world. Critics accuse the Chinese Government of hiding information and mishandling the deadly virus. Some countries, led by the United States (US), have even called it the “Chinese virus”.1 They have also accused the World Health Organisation (WHO) of collaborating with China and providing misinformation about the spread of the virus. However, most of the countries have avoided getting into the politics of it. The European Union (EU) had to tone down its report on China’s state-backed “global disinformation campaign” on the issue, as it feared that China might retaliate by withholding the much-needed medical supplies.2 The West Asian (or the Middle East) countries too have largely stayed out of the blame game and remain neutral.
With the US revitalising its domestic petroleum production through fracking and reducing dependency on the West Asian sources, it is likely to be a relatively less valuable customer than China. Today, Beijing is one of the region’s lead trade partners, importing about 40 per cent of its crude from the countries in West Asia.3 Furthermore, China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) and the capacity to invest and build infrastructure in developing countries, including in the health and education sector, have heightened the expectations among countries of the region. They view China as a potential source for diversifying their revenue streams amid apparent US retrenchment.
Besides, the way China has managed to control the outbreak and move towards economic recovery – while the European powers and the US and Russia have struggled – makes it a more attractive development partner amid the ongoing pandemic. The West Asian countries have in general been supportive of China especially as it struggled to contain the spread of the virus. On several occasions, the Burj Khalifa tower in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) was lit up with China’s national flag and the slogan “Wuhan Jiayou” (stay strong, Wuhan).4 Saudi Arabia, Qatar and Kuwait had initially donated medical supplies worth millions to China.5 In a surprising move, Turkey even ordered its local factories that normally manufactured clothing to produce antibacterial suits for supply to China.6
Meanwhile, in order to regain trust and portray itself as a benign pillar of international cooperation, China has resorted to soft diplomacy including in West Asia. Beijing is helping countries in the region to strengthen their healthcare infrastructure and has also provided medical and humanitarian supplies.
Seizing the Opportunity
President Donald Trump’s unilateral decision to withdraw US from the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action (JCPOA) or the Iran nuclear deal in May 2018, and the subsequent adoption of a “maximum pressure” policy against Iran, has provided Tehran with an opportunity to strengthen its ties with Beijing to escape global economic isolation. Iran considers China as one of its few trade outlets and a powerful ally in the international community. Whereas for China, Tehran is singularly crucial for strengthening BRI in the region.7
Iran was among the first countries to express its sympathies and send millions of medical masks to China.8 It also strongly condemned international criticism of the WHO and what it considered as groundless accusations against China.9 This speaks volumes about the nature of the relationship between the two countries.
The coronavirus soon unleashed havoc in Iran, making it the worst-affected country in the region. As of June 30, 2020, there were 227,662 confirmed cases and 10,817 deaths officially reported in the country.10 China expressed its support by supplying humanitarian goods and services,11 which assumes symbolic significance as the US attempts to bar Iran’s request for a $5 billion loan from the International Monetary Fund (IMF).12 China had also asked the US to ease sanctions on Iran, stating that they hamper Tehran’s ability to respond to the humanitarian crisis within the country and also makes it difficult for the United Nations (UN) and other international relief organisations to deliver aid.13
Similarly, Turkey, the second worst-hit country in the region, with 199,906 confirmed cases and 5,131 fatalities as of June 30,14 too has been looking to strengthen its strategic ties with China through trade and investment, and security and defence cooperation.15 Given the tensions with the European Union (EU) and the US, and also to reduce its reliance on the North Atlantic Treaty Organisation (NATO), Turkey has been looking for increased economic and political cooperation with other major powers like Russia and China. For Beijing, Turkey’s strategic location renders it a vital component in BRI’s global framework. At present, China provides essential supplies and other services including video conferencing between the medical experts of the two countries to share their experiences. Turkey is also reportedly using a “special drug” sent by China for patients suffering from the virus, cutting their time in intensive care from 11-12 to four days.16
However, the issue of Chinese treatment of its Turkic-speaking Uyghur Muslim population could continue to pose a challenge for the China-Turkey bilateral ties. It is reported that Uyghurs and other Turkic communities in China’s mass detention camps have limited or no access to healthcare or sanitation, leaving them extremely weak from malnutrition. This puts them at a much higher risk of infection from the virus.17 However, for now, both countries appear to be dealing with this issue amicably, keeping in mind their respective interests.
China has been helping the West Asian countries that have limited capacity to manufacture essential medical supplies. Iraq, Lebanon, Syria and Palestine have been provided ventilators, facemasks, swabs, test kits and protective gears for their doctors and paramedics. China has reportedly vowed to resist any attempts to cut off these exports.18
In Iraq, which has the world’s fifth-largest oil reserves and a strategic geopolitical location, China seems to have found the key as regards its aim to dominate trade across Asia and Europe. Iraq also serves as a bridge between Chinese shipping lanes in coastal countries like Israel, Turkey and several Gulf states.19 China has built a new Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) laboratory in Baghdad and has sent medical experts to the country to help contain the pandemic.20 The joint fight against COVID-19 will likely enhance cooperation and strengthen their strategic partnership.
The COVID-19 challenge has also provided China with an opportunity to further strengthen its ties with one of the US’ closest allies, Israel. Beijing has sent shipments of medical supplies21 and has fostered a partnership with Israel’s SmartAID healthcare company to set up laboratories and boost testing capacities in West Bank and Gaza to around 3,000 tests per day.22 Israel is a strong and technologically the most advanced country in the entire region. It remains a potential partner for China in areas like research and development, infrastructure projects, and science and technology. However, its stronger alliance with Washington limits its ties with Beijing despite cooperation on COVID-19. The US has expressed concerns about possible security consequences of increased cooperation between Israel and China.23 In the past, such concerns had forced many Israeli companies to withdraw from dealing with Chinese firms.24 China’s inflammatory rhetoric on Israel’s annexation of the Palestinian territories may become a source of tension in the future. Recently, the Chinese envoy to Israel stated that “all illegal acts” and “unilateral initiative aimed at legalizing settlement should be stopped immediately.”25 Though the Israeli Government did not issue an immediate response, it may not stay quiet in the long run.
In the wake of COVID-19, China is also collaborating with other Gulf Cooperation Council (GCC) countries. For example, China and Saudi Arabia have signed a deal worth more than $264 million in which China agreed to provide nine million testing kits and build at least six major laboratories in Saudi Arabia to increase its capacity to test 50,000 people per day for coronavirus.26 Moreover, China has expressed sincere gratitude to the UAE for protecting the health of its nationals during the outbreak.27 The country hosts more Chinese nationals than any other country in the Gulf region. Beijing has also provided medical and humanitarian assistance to Abu Dhabi. It is planning to run clinical trials, without naming the vaccine, on the COVID-19 patients in the UAE in future.28 Interestingly, both the UAE and Saudi Arabia are close allies of the US in the region.
In this time of crisis, when the US is engaged in dealing with several domestic issues, it seems to have little time for its allies and partners. President Trump’s public attitude towards America’s traditional allies in the region has not been entirely commensurate to their status. Meanwhile, China, with its deep pockets and alternative policy approaches, has been proactive in filling the space, challenging the American hegemony in world affairs. Beijing’s non-interference policy is a bonus for the leaders in the region.
China needs allies and markets to expand its economy. The COVID-19 crisis has given it an opportunity to further engage the West Asian countries where basic health infrastructure has been seriously affected by the pandemic. Providing medical assistance especially to conflict-prone countries such as Iraq, Lebanon, Syria and Palestine is part of China’s new soft diplomacy in the region, which is being heavily publicised by the Chinese state media’s Arabic-language outlets active in the region.29
China is also using the BRI ports and corridors to provide medical support to the countries in the region, for instance, the railway routes connecting Shanghai to Tehran and also Port Khalifa in Abu Dhabi. China has touted this as the “Health Silk Road”.30 It was in December 2015 when China’s National Health Commission first issued the guidelines for this initiative. Under the “Health Silk Road”, Beijing aims to improve health cooperation with the BRI countries. The objective is to increase the supply of Chinese drugs and other medical products across the globe. It also seeks to send health professionals to provide technical assistance and conduct training programmes in developing countries, and fund construction of hospitals and support capable pharmaceutical companies in building factories abroad.31 Countries like Iran, Turkey, Israel, Saudi Arabia and the UAE could become much-valued pieces of this project.
In the Chinese perception, Israel is considered as the bridge to the US.32 Similarly, Turkey is the gateway to Europe and countries like Iran, Saudi Arabia and the UAE are pivot countries in China’s global partnership network.
However, in West Asia, efforts to retain China’s attention reveals deeper insecurities about maintaining a relationship that is still fragile but considered as significant in times of COVID-19. While countries in the region will continue to follow a multi-vector foreign policy to expand their revenue streams, they are least likely to view China as a power that can replace the US in the region. China’s soft diplomacy in West Asia, particularly in times of pandemic, is more or less a way to improve its global image and recast itself as a responsible actor at relatively low cost, rather than a sign of any deeper commitment towards the region.
Views expressed are of the author and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Manohar Parrrikar IDSA or of the Government of India.
*About the author: Nagapushpa Devendra is Research Analyst at Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses
Source: This article was published by Manohar Parrikar Institute for Defence Studies and Analyses
- 1.See Donald J. Trump, Twitter Post, March 17, 2020, 4:21 AM.
- 2.Stuart Lau, “EU toned down report on Chinese disinformation after Beijing threatened ‘repercussions’, diplomatic sources say”, South China Morning Post, April 25, 2020.
- 3.“Factbox: Asia region is most dependent on Middle East crude oil, LNG supplies”, Reuters, January 08, 2020.
- 4.“Burj Khalifa lights up in red to show solidarity with China over coronavirus”, The Indian Express, February 04, 2020.
- 5.“Wang Yi Speaks by Phone with Deputy Prime Minister and Minister of Foreign Affairs Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin Jassim Al Thani of Qatar”, Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, April 01, 2020; and “Interview: Kuwait donates 3 mln USD medical supplies to China for fighting Covid-19: Chinese ambassador”, Xinhua, March 11, 2020.
- 6.“Turkish factory comes to China’s aid in Covid-19 fight”, Hurriyet Daily News, March 02, 2020.
- 7.China has invested around $3 billion to establish a high-speed rail connection linking Tehran, Qom and Isfahan; Kermanshah and Khosravi; and Tehran, Hamedan and Sanandaj. Beijing is also providing an additional $1.5 billion to electrify the Tehran-Mashhad trunk line. See Li Tianyang, “Belt & Road Initiative expands China-Iran cooperation”, China Daily, January 25, 2019.
- 8.Yang Sheng and Leng Shumei, “China returns favor with face masks, knowledge”, Global Times, March 01, 2020.
- 9.“Wang Yi Speaks by phone with Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif”, Chinese Ministry of Foreign Affairs, April 15, 2020; “Iran Condemns US Move to Halt Funding to WHO”, Iran Front Page, April 15, 2020; and “Iran condemns US’ coronavirus blame game against China”, Mehr News Agency, May 16, 2020.
- 10.“Health Ministry Confirms 147 New Deaths Caused by COVID-19”, Government of the Islamic Republic of Iran, June 30, 2020.
- 11.Zhang Hui, “China sends medics to Iran for virus control”, Global Times, February 29, 2020; and “China’s helps to Iran against coronavirus are unforgettable: Health Min Spox”, Iran Press, April 06, 2020.
- 12.Ian Talley and Benoit Faucon, “U.S. to Block Iran’s Request to IMF for $5 Billion Loan to Fight Coronavirus”, The Wall Street Journal, April 07, 2020.
- 13.“Foreign Ministry Spokesperson Geng Shuang’s Regular Press Conference on March 16, 2020”, Embassy of the People’s Republic of China in the United States of America, March 16, 2020.
- 14.“Turkey’s coronavirus caseload nears 200,000”, Daily Sabah, June 30, 2020.
- 15.“Stronger Turkish-Chinese strategic cooperation to support global stability”, Daily Sabah, July 03, 2020.
- 16.“Turkey using ‘special drug’ from China to treat coronavirus patients”, TRT World, March 23, 2020.
- 17.Munawwar Abdulla,“Coronavirus: China’s Xinjiang camps are a neglected high-risk area and should be closed”, Hong Kong Free Press, February 08, 2020.
- 18.“China publishes timeline on Covid-19 information sharing, int’l cooperation”, Xinhua, April 06, 2020.
- 19.Daniel J. Samet, “China, Not Iran, Is the Power to Watch in Iraq”, The Diplomat, October 30, 2019.
- 20.“Chinese-Built Lab Inaugurated In Baghdad To Contain Covid-19”, Outlook India, March 25, 2020.
- 21.“China sends 12 million masks to Israel to fight coronavirus”, Jerusalem Post, April 12, 2020.
- 22.“With Approval From Israeli And Palestinian Authorities, BGI And AID Genomics Announce Emergency Covid-19 Testing Lab In Gaza”, PR Newswire, April 06, 2020.
- 23.Ivan Levingston,“U.S. Official Warns Israel About Chinese Investors Amid Crisis”, Bloomberg, May 03, 2020.
- 24.“Trump said to warn PM security ties could suffer due to Israel-China relations”, The Times of Israel, April 14, 2020.
- 25.“China welcomes efforts of Israel, Palestine in fighting Covid-19”, Xinhua, March 31, 2020.
- 26.“Chinese firm cooperates with Saudi Arabia to build six Covid-19 testing labs”, Global Times, April 27, 2020.
- 27.“UAE Foreign Minister Commends China’s Outbreak Response and Contribution”, China Daily, April 11, 2020.
- 28.“UAE launches world’s first phase III clinical trial of inactivated COVID-19 vaccine”, UAE Ministry of Foreign Affairs & International Cooperation, June 24, 2020.
- 29.Mohammed Al-Sudairi, “Public Messaging’s Role in Shaping the Global Narrative of Coronavirus Outbreak”, The Arab Gulf States Institute in Washington, March 02, 2020.
- 30.“WHO Director-General’s opening remarks at high-level video conference on Belt and Road International Cooperation”, World Health Organisation, June 18, 2020.
- 31.“Major health exchange and cooperation on the Belt and Road Initiative”, National Health and Family Planning Commission of the PRC, December 18, 2015.
- 32.Israel’s former ambassador to China, Matan Vilnai, once stated that “We are important for them (China), because they see us as a bridge to America.” The Chinese “are convinced that we can influence inside the U.S. on things that will serve China.” See “Israel’s International Relations: Israel-China Relations”, The Jewish Virtual Library, A Project of The American-Israeli Cooperative Enterprise (AICE).