ISSN 2330-717X

Misleading Information On Demonetization In India – OpEd


Ever since India’s Prime Minister Narendra Modi announced the demonetization of high value currency, there have been repeated reports that the Indian economy has slowed down considerably.

While the government has pointed out that Rabi crop sowing has not slowed down and has only increased in the post demonetization period to highlight the fact that demonetization has no negative fundamental impact on growth and government has also pointed out that any slow down in other sectors are only temporary and not alarming, the media reports of note ban putting brake on the economy is persisting.

Misleading information

The latest news in the media is that the two wheeler, passenger vehicle and commercial vehicle sales have slumped and declined due to the note ban. Further, it is said that there has been revenue loss to the real estate industry to the level of around Rs.22600 cr. and the notional loss on stamp duty for the state governments is Rs.1200 Cr. The sales volume and launches of new projects have fallen by 23%.

The fact is that the demonetization only resulted in the withdrawal of high value currency notes. Transactions by cheque, bank transfers, credit/debit cards have continued without change.

The price of two wheelers and four wheelers are in the range of Rupees one lakh and above and there is no reason why such transactions should slow down because of demonetization. Obviously, this indicates that most of such transactions in the pre demonetization period have been taking place by cash (black money) and putting a brake on black money, hawala money and counterfeit notes have resulted in slow down in the sale of the automobiles.

The above reason is also applicable for the slow down in the real estate sector. It is very well known that in the last several years, most of the black money is dumped in the real estate by the tax evaders and black money holders, as a result of which the price of real estate has gone up by leaps and bounds, making it impossible for the people in the lower and lower middle income group to fulfill their dream of buying and owning a house.

Dr. Manmohan Singh’s misconception

Since demonetization on 8th November, 2016, some of the discretionary spending items such as lavish weddings have been impacted because a lot of black money is used for such expenses. The industries and other commercial sector, which are dependent for their business on spending in such highly discretionary items have been impacted, which is a short term happening.

The misleading campaign is that drop in such discretionary spending will lead to economic shock and contraction as growth in consumer consumption is a significant driver of economic growth. The former Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh, who should know better, has said that worst things are yet to happen in the country due to demonetization.

Should India allow parallel economy to persist?

Now, the question arises as to whether India should allow a parallel economy and growth based on ill-gained and tax-evaded money, which is at the cost of genuine tax payers and quality growth of he economy and the country?

This is precisely the objective of demonetization to reduce the role of black money in the economy and if the auto sales and real estate growth have really gone down after the demonetization shock, it only shows that the impact of black money in the economy has been considerably reduced and demonetization has a positive impact and is providing the expected results.

The recent demonetization had brought to light how the tax evaders had worked in connivance with corrupt officials to defeat the very process of clean up of the monetary system & tax governance .

Transparency in economic activity is the need of the day

Unmindful of the misleading information on demonetization being spread by some quarters and widely publicized in the media, Modi government should take stern action against the corrupt activities ruthlessly.

Of course, it has become difficult to enforce tax discipline in the country, since the legal system in India is not conducive for early disposal of cases and this again emboldens the corrupt elements. Had only the judicial system is more effective , many of the today’s black money holders and corrupt persons would have already been put behind bars.

With the black money largely gone, the economy will be back on healthy growth path soon when the transparent dealings would inevitably happen.

Click here to have Eurasia Review's newsletter delivered via RSS, as an email newsletter, via mobile or on your personal news page.

N. S. Venkataraman

N. S. Venkataraman is a trustee with the "Nandini Voice for the Deprived," a not-for-profit organization that aims to highlight the problems of downtrodden and deprived people and support their cause. To promote probity and ethical values in private and public life and to deliberate on socio-economic issues in a dispassionate and objective manner.

5 thoughts on “Misleading Information On Demonetization In India – OpEd

  • January 12, 2017 at 4:56 pm

    Good article good thinking golden era is to start from 2017as the weeds are removed. This is indian kamalahasan in action .gentle man arjun in action

  • January 12, 2017 at 6:19 pm

    This article is so far removed from reality and so naive, that it does not deserve even this criticism. Nevertheless… the benefits of this ill-conceived and ill-prepared demonetization is there on the ground for everyone to see. It has affected the ‘downtrodden and the deprived’ the most, not rich or the hoarders or black money. The psychological explanation for this type of rationalization is: deficit of empathy for suffering.

    • January 14, 2017 at 5:01 pm

      Not so. At an aggregate scale, farmers are only barely affected. Rabi numbers show it. Kirana has adapted shockingly fast, with massive embrace of epayment. Liquidity is also back faster than expected. Industrial output is up also. The suffering is massively overstated. The consequence is that the government will get a political windfall.

  • January 14, 2017 at 4:56 pm

    This article is spot-on. Indians can easily tell that the negative effects are being massively overstated in media and positive effects are being underplayed. However, India’s too open a country with massive information flows. 70 years of neocolonial and Indira Gandhi style Congressi propaganda has left the population almost immune to these things.

  • January 16, 2017 at 4:04 am

    Your article suffers from a serious misconception. There has been NO demonetization of high value notes. Instead an even higher value note of Rs. 2,000 has been introduced. But with the shortage created by withdrawal of Rs. 500 and Rs. 1000 notes, this new note also has turned unusable as no one has enough notes to make change for it. The common man (daily wage labor, street hawkers, household help etc.) who relied on cash are badly hit, not just back money using vehicle purchasers. Banks are busy tackling long angry queues of people wasting their time trying to get access to their own money ! How do you see so much unproductive effort helping the economy?


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.